─是《集》流行已久,缙绅之家,几于家置一编。每遇外症,照方抄服,幸而获效,群
以为
神。即或致误,不尤方之刺谬,而咎之无治。庚生侍先生临症数年,每见发背、乳岩等症,
误服阳和汤、犀黄丸而败者,不可胜算,心甚悯焉。特觅善本,请先生评正刊刻,庶读是书
者,知所采焉。
─不能红白二色分阴阳也。是《集》大旨,以分阴阳为主,而其分之之法,则不辨脉息
,不
分虚实,惟以色之红白为定。不知阴中有阳,阳中有阴;有真热,有假热;有真寒,有假寒
;若一概以色之红白为分,何能无误。
─外科不能不明脉理。无论痈疽疮疡,症虽现于外,病必由于内,即几微之疔毒癣疥,
亦必
内有火毒湿热,而后外发。其未发之先,脉必先见洪数弦滑等象。更有外症虽轻,而本原大
亏者;有内病与外症交发者。若非细辨脉理,何以别虚实寒热,标本先后乎?乃曰∶不谙脉
理,尽可救人。真如梦呓。
─外科不能不读《灵枢》、《素问》,肺痈、肺疽、肺痿,细辨脉象自知。《金匮》云
∶问
曰∶寸口脉数,其人咳,口中反有浊唾涎沫者何?师曰∶为肺痿之病。若口中辟辟燥,咳即
胸中隐隐痛,脉反滑数,此为肺痈。咳唾脓血,脉数虚者为肺痿,数实者为肺痈。是肺痈之
候,察脉便知,有何难觉?而曰诸患易识,肺痈难觉耶。惟其不谙脉理;不读《灵》、《素
》,以致如是。
─是《集》流传已久,辗转淆讹,贻误非浅。爰觅道光中裘氏本,重加订正,其分两一
切,悉仍其旧。惟加评语,以便采择。
─是《集》所选方药,半系疡科必不可少之方。其未加评语诸方,均平妥可用。惟药性
炮制诸法,太觉简略,当照《本草备要》、《雷公炮制》为是。
林屋散人言∶外科不谙脉理,可以救人。吴庚生驳之甚是。盖外科虽较内科稍易,如不
知脉
,仅辨外面形色,以红白为寒热,何以分其真假寒热,虚实阴阳耶?然脉学欲知其精细,毫
无错谬者,不但外科中少有其人,即求诸内科中亦不常有。如不识脉理人,可用予所作简便
医学寒暑表,测其寒热,亦可竟分明也。
阶臣记
这部《外科全生集》流传已久,士大夫人家,几乎家家户户都收藏有一部。每当遇到外科病症,就照着书里的方子抄录服用,侥幸获得疗效,大家便认为它是神效之书。即使偶尔导致误治,人们也不责怪方剂本身的谬误,反而归咎于医生没有治好。我(王洪绪)侍奉先生临诊数年,每次见到发背、乳岩等病症,因误服阳和汤、犀黄丸而导致病情恶化败坏的,数不胜数,心中十分怜悯。于是特意寻找善本,请先生评定校正后刊刻,希望读这本书的人,能够知道如何取舍。
不能仅凭红白两种颜色来区分阴阳。这部《集》的大旨,是以区分阴阳为主,但它区分的方法,却不辨别脉象呼吸,不区分虚实,只以颜色的红白作为定论。不知道阴中有阳,阳中有阴;有真热证,有假热证;有真寒证,有假寒证;如果一概以颜色的红白来划分,怎么能不出错呢?
外科不能不明白脉理。无论是痈疽疮疡,症状虽然表现在外部,但病根必定源于内部,即使是细微的疔毒癣疥,也必定是内部有火毒湿热,然后才在外部发作。在病症未发作之前,脉象必然先出现洪、数、弦、滑等征象。更有甚者,外部症状虽然轻微,但人体本源大亏的;有内部疾病与外部症状同时发作的。如果不仔细辨别脉理,凭什么来区别虚实证、寒热证以及标本先后呢?书中却说:“不通晓脉理,也可以救人。”这真是如同梦话一般。
外科不能不读《灵枢》和《素问》,对于肺痈、肺疽、肺痿,仔细辨别脉象自然就能知晓。《金匮要略》说:有人问:“寸口脉数,病人咳嗽,口中反而有浑浊的唾沫涎液,这是什么原因?”医生说:“这是肺痿的病。如果口中干燥,一咳嗽就胸中隐隐作痛,脉象反而滑数,这是肺痈。咳嗽吐脓血,脉数而虚的是肺痿,脉数而实的是肺痈。”由此可见,肺痈的症状,通过察脉就能知道,有什么难察觉的呢?书中却说各种病患容易识别,唯独肺痈难以察觉。正是因为不通晓脉理,不读《灵枢》、《素问》,才导致这样的错误。
这部《集》流传已久,辗转传抄导致混乱讹误,贻害非浅。因此寻找道光年间的裘氏版本,重新加以订正,其中的药物分量一切照旧。只是增加了评语,以便读者参考选择。
这部《集》所选的方药,有一半是疡科(外科)必不可少的方剂。那些没有加评语的方子,都是平妥可用的。只是关于药性炮制的方法,显得太简略,应当参照《本草备要》、《雷公炮炙法》才是正确的。
林屋散人说:“外科如果不通晓脉理,也可以救人。”吴庚生对此驳斥得非常正确。大概外科虽然比内科稍容易一些,但如果不知脉象,仅仅辨别外部的形色,以红白来判断寒热,凭什么来分辨真假寒热、虚实阴阳呢?然而,想要精通脉学,做到毫厘不差,不仅在外科医生中少见,即使在内科医生中也并不常有。如果不识脉理的人,可以使用我所著的简便医学寒暑表,测量其寒热情况,也可以分辨得清清楚楚。
阶臣记
This *Ji* (Collection) has been in circulation for a long time, and among the gentry families, almost every household possesses a copy. Whenever external diseases occur, they copy and administer the prescriptions from the book. By chance, if efficacy is achieved, the masses regard it as divine. Even if errors are caused, people do not blame the prescription itself for its absurdity, but rather blame the physician for failing to cure. During my several years of attending the Master during clinical practice, I have frequently seen cases of back carbuncles (Fabei) and breast cancer (Ruyan), etc., which were ruined by the mistaken administration of Yanghe Tang (Warm Harmony Decoction) and Xihuang Wan (Rhino Horn Pill), the number of which is incalculable; my heart was deeply moved with pity. Therefore, I sought out a good edition, requested the Master to review and correct it for publication, so that readers of this book might know what to adopt.
One cannot distinguish Yin and Yang solely based on red and white colors. The main purport of this *Ji* is to distinguish Yin and Yang, yet its method of distinction does not differentiate pulse and respiration, nor does it distinguish deficiency and excess; it merely takes the redness or whiteness of color as the criterion. It fails to realize that within Yin there is Yang, and within Yang there is Yin; that there are true heat patterns and false heat patterns; true cold patterns and false cold patterns. If one uniformly distinguishes based on the redness or whiteness of color, how can errors be avoided?
Surgery cannot proceed without understanding pulse theory. Regardless of whether it is an abscess, ulcer, sore, or swelling, although the symptoms manifest externally, the disease must originate internally. Even minor conditions like carbuncle poison, tinea, or scabies must have internal fire toxin, damp-heat, etc., before manifesting externally. Before the onset of symptoms, the pulse must first exhibit images such as surging (Hong), rapid (Shu), wiry (Xian), or slippery (Hua). Furthermore, there are cases where external symptoms are mild but the root constitution is severely depleted; there are cases where internal diseases and external symptoms erupt simultaneously. Without carefully distinguishing pulse theory, how can one differentiate between deficiency and excess, cold and heat, and the root and branch, as well as their sequence? Yet the book states: "Not knowing pulse theory, one can still save lives." This is truly like talking in one's sleep.
Surgery cannot avoid studying the *Ling Shu* (Spiritual Pivot) and *Su Wen* (Basic Questions); regarding lung abscess (Fei Yong), lung gangrene (Fei Ju), and lung flaccidity (Fei Wei), careful differentiation of pulse images will reveal the diagnosis naturally. The *Jin Gui Yao Lue* (Essential Prescriptions of the Golden Cabinet) states: Someone asked, "The pulse at the cunkou position is rapid, the person coughs, yet instead has turbid saliva and froth in the mouth. What is the reason?" The Master said, "This is the disease of lung flaccidity (Fei Wei). If the mouth is dry and crackling, and coughing causes hidden pain in the chest, while the pulse is surprisingly slippery and rapid, this is lung abscess (Fei Yong). Coughing up pus and blood with a rapid and deficient pulse indicates lung flaccidity (Fei Wei); a rapid and excess pulse indicates lung abscess (Fei Yong)." Thus, the signs of lung abscess (Fei Yong) can be known by observing the pulse; what is difficult about perceiving them? Yet the book claims that various ailments are easy to recognize, but lung abscess (Fei Yong) is hard to perceive. This is precisely because of ignorance of pulse theory and failure to study the *Ling Shu* and *Su Wen*, leading to such errors.
This *Ji* has been circulated for a long time, passed down through generations with confusion and errors, causing significant harm. Therefore, I sought the Qiu family edition from the Daoguang era, re-corrected it, keeping all drug dosages exactly as they were. Only comments were added to facilitate selection.
The prescriptions and herbs selected in this *Ji* are half indispensable for surgery (Yangke). All prescriptions without added comments are balanced, safe, and usable. However, the methods regarding drug properties and processing are too brief; it would be proper to refer to *Bencao Bei Yao* (Compendium of Materia Medica Prepared for Use) and *Leigong Paozhi* (Leigong's Processing Methods).
Linwu Sanren stated: "In surgery, not knowing pulse theory, one can still save lives." Wu Gengsheng refuted this very correctly. Generally speaking, although surgery is slightly easier than internal medicine, if one does not know the pulse and only differentiates external appearance and color, using redness and whiteness to judge cold and heat, how can one distinguish between true/false cold and heat, and deficiency/excess and Yin/Yang? However, to master pulse studies finely and without error is rare not only among surgeons but also among internists. For those who do not understand pulse theory, using the simple medical thermometer I authored to measure cold and heat can also yield clear results.
Recorded by Jiechen