参附汤(补三七) 五味子汤(补五七 喘渴) 十全大补汤(补二十 虚喘) 蜜酥煎(补
六五) 百合汤(和一三五 浮肿作喘) 人参胡桃汤(补五九 喘不得卧) 苏子煎(和一四一
润肺喘) 定喘汤(和一三三 风寒喘) 人参定喘汤(和一三四 寒邪咳喘) 黄栝蒌丸(和
百十八 痰喘) 神秘汤(和一三八 水气喘) 苏陈九宝汤(散八五 哮喘) 泻白散(寒四二
肺火) 双玉散(寒七一 火喘) 安眠散(固七 喘不止) 葶苈大枣泻肺汤(和百四十 浮
肿喘)
《口问篇帝》曰∶人之哕者,何气使然?岐伯曰∶谷入于胃,胃气上注于肺。今有故寒
气与新谷气俱还入于胃,新故相乱,真邪相攻,气并相逆,复出于胃,故为哕。肺主为哕,
取手太阴,足少阴。
《宣明五气篇》曰∶胃为气逆,为哕为恐。
《杂病篇》曰∶哕,以草刺鼻,嚏,嚏而已;无息而疾迎引之,立已;大惊之,亦可已。
《至真要大论》曰∶阳明之复,呕吐咳哕。太阳之复,唾出清水,及为哕噫。诸逆冲上,皆属于火。
《宝命全角论》曰∶病深者,其声哕。
《邪气脏腑病形篇》曰∶心脉小甚为善哕。
《三部九候论》曰∶若有七诊之病,其脉候亦败者死矣,必发哕噫。
呃逆一证,古无是名,其在《内经》本谓之哕,因其呃呃连声,故今以呃逆名之,于义
亦妥。观《内经》治哕之法,以草刺鼻,嚏,及气息迎引、大惊之类,是皆治呃之法,此
哕本呃逆,无待辨也。自孙真人云∶遍寻方论无此名,遂以咳逆为哕,因致后世讹传,乃以
咳逆、干呕、噫气之类互相肴乱,自唐迄今矣,此名之不可不察,亦不可不正也。
一、咳逆之名,原出《内经》,本以咳嗽气逆者为言。如《气交变大论》曰∶岁金太过
,甚则喘咳逆气。此因喘咳以致气逆,故云咳逆气也。又曰∶咳逆甚而血溢。正以咳逆不止
,而血随气溢,则病之常也,未闻以呃逆而见血者也。即如《六元正纪大论》云∶金郁之发
,民病咳逆者,亦是此意,此咳逆之非呃逆亦甚明矣。而今后世诸公,乃悉以哕为咳逆,岂
皆未之详察耶?及观丹溪之言,在《纂要》则曰∶孙真人误以哕为咳逆。是谓哕非咳逆也。
在《心法·附录》则曰∶咳逆为病,古谓之哕,近谓之呃。此又谓哕即咳逆也。在呕吐门则
又曰∶有声有物谓之呕吐,有声无物谓之哕。此又以干呕为哕也。前后不一,何其自谬若此
。再如海藏、河间诸公,有以哕为干呕者,有以咳逆为噫者,总皆谬矣。盖呕即吐之类,但
吐而无物者曰呕,呕而有物者曰吐,腹胀嗳气者曰噫,逆气自下而上者亦曰噫,此四者之辨
自有正名,顾可纷纷若是乎?兹余析而判之曰∶哕者,呃逆也,非咳逆也。咳逆者,咳嗽之
甚者也,非呃逆也。干呕者,无物之吐,即呕也,非哕也。噫者,饱食之息,即嗳气也,非
咳逆也。后人但以此为鉴,则异说之疑,可尽释矣。
一、呃逆证,有伤寒之呃逆,有杂证之呃逆。其在古人则悉以虚寒为言,惟丹溪引《内
经》之言曰∶诸逆冲上,皆属于火,病患见此,似为死证,然亦有实者,不可不知。余向见
此说,疑其与古人相左,不以为然,盖亦谓此证必属虚寒,何有实热,兹及晚年历验,始有
定见,乃知丹溪此言为不诬也。虽其中寒热虚实亦有不同,然致呃之由,总由气逆,气逆于
下,则直冲于上,无气则无呃,无阳亦无呃,此病呃之源所以必由气也。欲得其象,不见雨
中之雷,水中之 乎。夫阳为阴蔽,所以为雷,而轰轰不已者,此火为雷之本,而火即
气也。气为水覆,所以为 而 不已者,此气为 之本,而气即阳也。然病在
气分,非本一端,而呃之大要,亦惟三者而已,则一曰寒呃,二曰热呃,三曰虚脱之呃,寒
呃可温可散,寒去则气自舒也。热呃可降可清,火静而气自平也。惟虚脱之呃,则诚危殆之
证,其或免者,亦万幸矣。凡诸治法,当辨如下。
参附汤(用于补益三七阶段) 五味子汤(用于补益五七阶段,治疗气喘口渴) 十全大补汤(用于补益二十岁阶段,治疗虚性气喘) 蜜酥煎(用于补益六五阶段) 百合汤(用于调和一三五阶段,治疗浮肿伴气喘) 人参胡桃汤(用于补益五九阶段,治疗气喘不能平卧) 苏子煎(用于调和一四一阶段,润肺治疗气喘) 定喘汤(用于调和一三三阶段,治疗风寒所致气喘) 人参定喘汤(用于调和一三四阶段,治疗寒邪引起的咳嗽气喘) 黄栝蒌丸(用于调和百十八阶段,治疗痰饮所致气喘) 神秘汤(用于调和一三八阶段,治疗水气所致气喘) 苏陈九宝汤(用于发散八五阶段,治疗哮喘) 泻白散(用于清泻寒四二阶段的肺火) 双玉散(用于清泻寒七一阶段的火性气喘) 安眠散(用于固摄七阶段,治疗气喘不止) 葶苈大枣泻肺汤(用于调和百四十阶段,治疗浮肿气喘)
《灵枢·口问篇》记载:黄帝问岐伯说:人发生呃逆(古称哕),是什么气导致的?岐伯回答说:食物进入胃中,胃气向上注入肺脏。现在如果有旧的寒气与新入的食物之气同时回到胃中,新旧之气相互扰乱,正气与邪气相互冲突,气机并合且逆乱,再次从胃中冲出,所以发生呃逆。肺主司呃逆的发生,治疗应取手太阴肺经和足少阴肾经的穴位。
《素问·杂病论》记载:对于呃逆,可以用草刺激鼻子引起喷嚏,喷嚏打出来就好了;或者屏住呼吸并快速引导气息下行,立刻就能停止;或者突然惊吓患者,也可以治愈。
《素问·至真要大论》记载:阳明经之气复返,会出现呕吐、咳嗽和呃逆。太阳经之气复返,会出现唾出清水以及呃逆嗳气。所有气机上冲的症状,都归属于火。
《素问·宝命全形论》记载:病情深重的患者,其声音表现为呃逆。
《素问·三部九候论》记载:如果患有“七诊”所示的重病,且脉象也已败坏,则预后不良会死亡,必定会出现呃逆和嗳气。
呃逆这一证候,古代没有这个名称,在《内经》中原本称为“哕”,因为发出呃呃的声音连续不断,所以现在称之为呃逆,这在义理上也是妥当的。观察《内经》治疗哕的方法,如用草刺鼻引起喷嚏,以及调节呼吸迎引气息、大惊疗法等,这些都是治疗呃逆的方法,这说明哕就是呃逆,无需辨别。自从孙思邈说:“遍寻方论没有这个名称”,于是将咳逆当作哕,导致后世讹传,把咳逆、干呕、嗳气之类互相混淆,从唐代到现在都是如此,这个名称不可不考察,也不可不正名。
第一、咳逆之名,原本出自《内经》,本意是指咳嗽伴有气逆。如《素问·气交变大论》说:岁金太过,严重时会出现喘息咳嗽气逆。这是因为喘息咳嗽导致气逆,所以说咳逆气。又说:咳逆严重而血溢。正是由于咳逆不止,血液随气溢出,这是疾病的常态,没听说过因呃逆而出血的。就像《素问·六元正纪大论》说:金郁发作时,百姓患病咳逆,也是这个意思,这清楚地表明咳逆不是呃逆。然而后世的各位医生,却全部把哕当作咳逆,难道都没有详细考察吗?再看朱丹溪的话,在《丹溪纂要》中说:孙真人错误地把哕当作咳逆。这是说哕不是咳逆。在《丹溪心法·附录》中说:咳逆这种病,古代叫哕,近代叫呃。这又说哕就是咳逆。在呕吐门中又说:有声有物叫做呕吐,有声无物叫做哕。这又把干呕当作哕了。前后不一致,为什么自己谬误到这种地步。再如张元素(海藏)、刘完素(河间)诸位医生,有的把哕当作干呕,有的把咳逆当作嗳气,全都是错误的。大概呕吐属于吐的一类,但只吐而无物的叫呕,呕而有物的叫吐,腹胀嗳气的叫噫,气自下而上逆的叫噫,这四者的区别自有正确的名称,怎么能如此纷乱呢?现在我分析并判定说:哕,就是呃逆,不是咳逆。咳逆,是咳嗽严重的表现,不是呃逆。干呕,是无物的吐,就是呕,不是哕。噫,是饱食后的气息,就是嗳气,不是咳逆。后人以此为鉴,那么各种异说的疑惑,就可以完全消除了。
第二、呃逆证,有伤寒引起的呃逆,有杂病引起的呃逆。在古人那里,全都说是由虚寒引起的,只有朱丹溪引用《内经》的话说:所有气机上冲的症状,都归属于火。病人见到这种情况,似乎是死证,但也有实证,不可不知道。我以前看到这种说法,怀疑它与古人相左,不以为然,认为此证必然属于虚寒,怎么会有实热呢?到了晚年经过反复验证,才有了确定的见解,才知道朱丹溪的话是不虚假的。虽然其中寒热虚实也有不同,但导致呃逆的原因,总归是气逆,气在下部逆乱,就直接冲向上部,没有气就没有呃逆,没有阳也没有呃逆,这就是呃逆的病源必然源于气的原因。想要理解它的形象,不妨看看雨中的雷声,水中的气泡翻涌吧。阳气被阴气遮蔽,所以形成雷,而轰轰不停止的,这是火作为雷的根本,而火就是气。气被水覆盖,所以形成气泡翻涌而不停止的,这是气作为气泡的根本,而气就是阳。然而病在气分,并非只局限于一端,而呃逆的大要,也只有这三种情况罢了,即一是寒呃,二是热呃,三是虚脱之呃。寒呃可以用温法或散法,寒气去除则气自然舒展。热呃可以用降法或清法,火静下来则气自然平和。只有虚脱之呃,确实是危殆的证候,能幸免的,也是万幸了。凡是各种治疗方法,应当辨析如下。
Shenfu Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Aconite Decoction) [indicated for tonification at age 37] Wuzi Wan (Five-Seed Decoction) [indicated for tonification at age 49, treating panting and thirst] Shiquan Dabu Tang (Complete Great Tonifying Decoction) [indicated for tonification at age 20, treating deficiency-type panting] Misu Jian (Honey and Butter Decoction) [indicated for tonification at age 65] Baihe Tang (Lily Decoction) [indicated for harmonization at ages 13, 35, and others, treating edema with panting] Renshen Hetao Tang (Ginseng and Walnut Decoction) [indicated for tonification at age 59, treating panting preventing supine position] Suzi Jian (Perilla Seed Decoction) [indicated for harmonization at age 41, moistening the Lung to treat panting] Dingchuan Tang (Panting-Stopping Decoction) [indicated for harmonization at age 33, treating wind-cold panting] Renshen Dingchuan Tang (Ginseng Panting-Stopping Decoction) [indicated for harmonization at age 34, treating cough and panting due to cold pathogen] Huangguawa Wan (Yellow Trichosanthes Pill) [indicated for harmonization at age 80, treating phlegm-panting] Shenmi Tang (Mysterious Decoction) [indicated for harmonization at age 38, treating water-qig panting] Suchen Jiubao Tang (Perilla and Chenpi Nine-Treasures Decoction) [indicated for dispersal at age 5, treating asthma] Xiebai San (Draining White Powder) [indicated for clearing heat at stage 42, treating Lung fire] Shuangyu San (Double Jade Powder) [indicated for clearing heat at stage 71, treating fire-type panting] Anmian San (Sleep-Calming Powder) [indicated for consolidating at stage 7, treating intractable panting] Tingli Dazao Xiefei Tang (Descurainia Seed and Jujube Decoction to Drain the Lung) [indicated for harmonization at age 40, treating edema with panting]
The *Kouwen* Chapter of the *Lingshu* states: The Yellow Emperor asked Qibo, "What qi causes hiccups (anciently termed 'yue')?" Qibo replied, "When food enters the stomach, Stomach qi flows upward into the Lungs. If old cold qi and new food qi both return to the stomach, the new and old interfere with each other, true qi and evil qi clash, qi merges and reverses, and re-emerges from the stomach; thus, hiccups occur." The Lungs govern hiccups; treatment should select points from the Hand-Taiyin Lung Meridian and Foot-Shaoyin Kidney Meridian.
The *Xuanming Wuqi* Chapter of the *Suwen* states: "Stomach qi rebellion leads to qi reversal, hiccups, and fear."
The *Zabing* Chapter of the *Suwen* states: "For hiccups, prick the nose with grass to induce sneezing; once sneezed, it stops. Alternatively, hold the breath and quickly guide the qi downward, and it will stop immediately. Sudden fright can also cure it."
The *Zhiyao Dalun* Chapter of the *Suwen* states: "When Yangming qi rebounds, vomiting, coughing, and hiccups occur. When Taiyang qi rebounds, spitting clear fluid and hiccups/belching occur. All rebellious qi rushing upward belongs to Fire."
The *Baoming Quanxing* Chapter of the *Suwen* states: "In severe disease, the voice manifests as hiccups."
The *Xieqi Zangfu Binxing* Chapter of the *Lingshu* states: "A very small Heart pulse indicates a predisposition to hiccups."
The *Sanbu Jiuhou* Chapter of the *Suwen* states: "If one suffers from diseases indicated by the 'Seven Diagnoses' and the pulse is also depleted, death is imminent, accompanied by hiccups and belching."
The syndrome of hiccupping was not named as such in ancient times; in the *Neijing*, it was originally called 'yue'. Because it produces continuous 'e-e' sounds, it is now called 'ehni' (hiccup), which is semantically appropriate. Observing the methods for treating 'yue' in the *Neijing*, such as pricking the nose to induce sneezing, regulating breath to guide qi downward, and using sudden fright, these are all methods for treating hiccups. This confirms that 'yue' is indeed hiccupping, requiring no distinction. Since Sun Simiao stated, "I have searched all formulas and theories but found no such name," he equated 'yue' with 'ke ni' (cough-reversal), leading to later errors where 'ke ni', dry retching, and belching were confused. From the Tang Dynasty to the present, this confusion has persisted. This nomenclature must be investigated and corrected.
First, the term 'ke ni' originates from the *Neijing*, originally referring to coughing with qi rebellion. For example, the *Jiaobi Daolun* states: "When Metal Qi is excessive, severe cases involve panting, coughing, and qi rebellion." This refers to qi rebellion caused by panting and coughing, hence 'ke ni qi'. It further states: "Severe ke ni leads to blood溢 (overflow)." This means when ke ni does not cease, blood overflows with qi, which is the normal progression of the disease; there is no record of bleeding caused by hiccups. Similarly, the *Liuyuan Zhengji Dalun* states: "When Metal Depression occurs, people suffer from ke ni," indicating that ke ni is clearly not hiccups. Yet modern physicians all equate 'yue' with 'ke ni'. Have they not examined this carefully? Zhu Danxi, in his *Zuanyao*, stated: "Sun Simiao mistakenly equated yue with ke ni," implying yue is not ke ni. However, in the *Xinfa Fulu*, he wrote: "Ke ni, in ancient times called yue, in recent times called e," implying yue is ke ni. In the Vomiting section, he said: "Sound with matter is vomiting; sound without matter is yue," equating yue with dry retching. These statements are inconsistent and self-contradictory. Zhang Yuansu (Haizang) and Liu Wansu (Hejian) also erred, some equating yue with dry retching, others with belching. Vomiting and spitting differ only by the presence of matter; belching ('yi') is gas from fullness or rising qi. These four have distinct names and should not be confused. I analyze and judge thus: 'Yue' is hiccupping, not ke ni. 'Ke ni' is severe coughing, not hiccupping. 'Dry retching' is vomiting without matter, not 'yue'. 'Yi' is belching after eating, not ke ni. Let future generations take this as a warning, so that doubts regarding these differing theories may be resolved.
Second, hiccupping syndromes include those from Cold-Damage and those from miscellaneous diseases. Ancients generally attributed them to deficiency-cold. Only Zhu Danxi cited the *Neijing*: "All rebellious qi rushing upward belongs to Fire." Patients presenting this might seem to face a fatal prognosis, but excess patterns exist and must be known. I previously doubted this view, thinking it contradicted ancients and that hiccups must be deficiency-cold, lacking excess-heat. However, through extensive verification in my later years, I formed a definitive opinion and realized Zhu Danxi was correct. Although cold, heat, deficiency, and excess vary, the cause of hiccups is always qi rebellion. Qi rebelling below rushes directly upward; without qi, there are no hiccups; without Yang, there are no hiccups. Thus, the source of hiccups lies in qi. To understand its nature, observe thunder in rain or bubbles in water. Yang obscured by Yin creates thunder; the roaring sound stems from Fire, which is Qi. Qi covered by Water creates bubbles; the bubbling stems from Qi, which is Yang. Disease in the Qi aspect is not limited to one end. The main types of hiccups are three: Cold Hiccup, Heat Hiccup, and Collapse Hiccup. Cold Hiccups can be treated with warming and dispersing methods; removing cold allows qi to relax. Heat Hiccups can be treated with descending and clearing methods; calming fire allows qi to level out. Collapse Hiccups are truly critical conditions; survival is rare. Treatment methods should be differentiated as follows.