黄 疸 门
面黑目黄,脉数而微,足寒至膝,皮肤爪甲不仁。其病深入少阴,而其邪则仍白酒湿得之及女劳也。
诒按:此证载在《金匮》,近于《爱庐医案》中,见一方甚佳。此病兼有瘀血,不但湿也。 肾气丸能否见效,尚未可定。
邓评:此病肾阳固虚,营卫自乏,而湿热瘀血亦必相兼。此方似嫌专顾其虚,未能祛邪。
面目身体悉黄,而中无痞闷,小便自利。此仲景所谓虚黄也。即以仲景法治之。
诒按:案明药当。
邓评:如此认证,便觉了无疑义。引用古方,亦自确切不泛。
湿停热聚,上逆则咽嗌不利,外见则身目为黄,下注则溺赤而痛。
诒按:论病能一线穿成,用药自丝丝入筘。
又按:咽嗌不利,可加桔梗,前胡之类。
痹 气 门
胸背为阳之分,痹着不通,当通其阳,盖阳不外行而郁于中,则内反热而外反寒。通阳必以辛温,而辛温又碍于脏气,拟辛润通肺以代之。
邓评:此似《金匮》所论之胸痹证,瓜萎薤白半夏之属,能通阳而不碍脏气,屏除不用,何以故耶?或者独任此味,曾已试验。
邓评:此热郁于内,肺气不宣,故但宜轻开上焦,未便因外寒而投姜、桂热药。
气窒不散,便闭喘急,不能偃卧,猝难消散也。
邓评:因邪已化热,故转方改用寒下。
胸中为阳之位,阳气不布,则窒而不通。宜温通,不宜清刀:,愈开则愈窒矣。
诒按:再参入开痹之品,如杏、菀、橘、桔等,似更灵动。
孙评:杏、菀、橘、桔,即所云愈开愈窒者。
邓评:饮阻气郁,阳络易窒,辛通固所必需,如木香、砂仁疏畅中气之品,还宜参入。
脘 腹 痛 门
邓评:方与证合。惟蛔厥确据,尚有心下苦热,痛则攻触有形见端,或唇舌面色变现不定,盖随蛔之动静故也。
诒按:寒袭于肾,而气上逆,故用温养。胀及腰背者,督阳不用也。鹿茸温通督脉,麝香开泄浊阴,故以主为君。
孙评:气自脐下上逆面厥,故名肾厥;四肢寒冷,故用温养,背重于胸,故用茸、麝。
脉弦小腹痛,食后胃脘痛,上至咽嗌。肝火乘胃。宜泄厥阴、和阳明。
邓评:病因食后面作,是胃气被遏而不畅,与得食则缓者有虚实之异,鼓此方务取琉泄。
诒按:立方稳合。
瘕 癖 门
脐下积块,扪之则热,病者自宫,前后二阴,俱觉热痛,其为热结可知。况自来之病,皆出于肝耶。鄙见非泄厥阴,不能获效。
龙荟丸五十粒酒下
络病瘀痹,左胁板实,前年用虫蚁,通血升降开发已效,伹胸皖似是有形,按之微痛。前药太峻,兹用两调气血,以缓法图之。
醋炒延胡 姜黄 阿魏 桃仁 生香附 麝香 归须 为末蜜丸每服二钱
脉虚数,色白不泽。左胁有块杯大,大便小便自利。病在肝家,营血不和,此为虚中有实,补必兼通。
白术 归身 炙草 白芍 生地 茯苓 琥珀 广皮 桃仁 红花 沉香 郁金
诒桉;方治亲切不肤。
邓评:古人论治块有初中末三法,此即中途之治,但似可加用人参。
时病食复,至今不知饥饱,大便不爽,右胁之旁,虚里天枢,隐隐有形。此阳明胃络循行之所,多暖气不化,并不烦渴,岂是攻消急驱实热之证耶。拟用丹溪泄木安上法。
小温中丸 如半月后有效仍以前法
诒按:此中焦湿积阻结之证。
左胁积块,日以益大,按之则痛,食入不安。凡痞结之处,必有阳火郁伏于中,故见烦躁口干心热等证。宜以苦辛寒药,清之开之。然非易事也。
诒按:胁块有形益大,则营络必窒,似宜荣通乃效。
邓评:凡积块系时久体虚者,极难奏绩。
方药稳切,再参用金铃子散可也。
心下高突,延及左胁有形,渐加腹胀。思正月暴寒,口鼻吸受冷气,入胃络膜原,清阳不用,浊阴凝阻,胃气重伤,有单腹之累,殊非小恙。
另苏合香丸一粒化服。
邓评;高突有形,似宜兼通营络。
肿 胀 门
诒按:此温中调气法也。
邓评:此缘中寒木郁,于温中方内,宜增白芍、金铃子、木瓜以平调其肝木。再槟榔一味,不识何所取用。
孙评:湿中生热,故术、柏并用。
脉微迟,左胁宿痞,腹渐胀大,便溏溺少。此是浊阴上攻,当与通阳。
邓评:此乃中虚湿热,兼有肝气内乘,方内附子易干姜为稳;远志不知从何取义?拟增白术、金铃子、青皮。
脾气本弱,而更受木克,克则益弱矣,由是脾健失职,食入不消,遂生胀满;脾愈弱则肝愈强,时时攻逆,上下有声。半载之疾,年逾六旬,非旦夕可图也。
诒按:此肝脾两治,而偏重于肝者,以其不特胀满,而兼有攻逆之证也。
邓评:案语辨理明晰,方意虚实兼到。
右关独大而搏指,知病在中焦,饮食不化,痞闷时痛,积年不愈,喉间自觉热气上冲,口干作苦,舌苔白燥。此脾家积热郁湿。当以泻黄法治之。
诒按:此痞满门中不常见之证,存之以备一格。
邓评:右关独大,是亦有肝木之火乘于中上也,盖不独积热使然。方法背谬,惟石膏究属不及川连为合度。
脉证合参,乃气结在上,津不运行,蒸变浊痰,由无形渐变有形。徐之才谓轻可去实,非胶固阴药所宜。
诒按:此方具有轻,清、灵三字之妙。
邓评:此病滋补阴药必已误服多矣,故立论如是。
劳郁交伤,营卫不和,胸中满痛,时有寒热。与六淫外感不同。治宜和养气血。
诒按:再增枳、朴等宽中之品,则更周到矣。
邓评:病虽非外感,而肝经亦有伏邪郁火。方法颇合,再增枳、朴理气,则更善矢。
脾以健运为职,心下痞不能食,食则满闷,脾失其职矣。但健运之品,迂缓无功,宜以补泻升降法治之。
胁下素有痞气,时时冲逆;今见中满,气攻作痛,吞酸呕吐,能俯而不能仰。此厥阴郁滞之气,侵入太阴之分,得之多怒且善郁也。病久气弱,不任攻达;而病气久郁,亦难补养为掣肘耳。姑以平调肝胃之剂和之,痛定食进,方许万全。
诒按:审察病机,至为精细,立方亦周到熨帖。
不得已而立一乎调郁气之方,亦限于时局如此。
孙评:议论透彻。
孙评:二症似乎相同,一则阳衰宜温,一则化热宜清。然温不用桂、附,非下焦阳衰也:热不用连、军,非结闭之甚也,同中有异,宜细参之。
腹胀\面浮、跗肿,食不下,欲呕。脾虚受湿,健运失常。非轻证也。
面黑,目黄,腹满,足肿,囊肿。湿热壅滞,从脾及肾,病深难治。
诒按:邪机壅滞,正气已伤,故云难治。
邓评书此等病明知正气已伤,亦只得以驱导为法,为背城借一之计。
孙评:急泻其壅滞,以存其正,或可挽回。此则正气未致大伤者之法,另是一格。
卧则喘息有音,此肿胀,乃气壅于上。宜用古人开鬼门之法,以治肺通表。
邓评:此系仲景成法,为的对之方。即使正气稍伤,仅以麻黄换苏子可也。
邓评:病似风水,立方不拘仲景成法,想因病势稍轻,或以正气受伤,贵乎随机应变者也。
肿胀之病,而二便如常,肢冷气喘。是非行气逐水之法所能愈者矣。当用肾气丸,行阳化水。然亦剧病也。
诒按:此病阳衰气窒,不治之证也。
头 痛 门
疟疾停止后再次发作,出汗多且伴有呕吐,这是中气虚弱导致的气机上逆,适宜补益阳明经。
复诊:寒热症状已经停止,出汗和呕吐都减轻了。适宜调和并滋养营卫。
诒按:这是针对饮食肥甘厚味导致虚损体质的治法,两个方子都清润稳妥、熨帖得当。
邓评:痰热已经消退,营卫更加显得虚弱,所以转换方剂专门滋养营卫。
黄疸门
面色黑而眼睛黄,脉象数而微弱,脚冷直到膝盖,皮肤和指甲感觉麻木不仁。病情深入少阴经,但致病邪气仍然是因为饮用白酒湿气以及房劳所致。
诒按:此证记载在《金匮要略》中,近见于《爱庐医案》,其中一方甚佳。此病兼有瘀血,不仅仅是湿邪。肾气丸能否见效,还不确定。
邓评:此病肾阳确实虚弱,营卫自然匮乏,而湿热瘀血也必然相兼存在。此方似乎只顾及了虚证,未能祛除邪气。
孙评:黄疸伴有瘀血发黑的情况,道理是可以相通的,这又增加了一种解释。
面目身体全部发黄,但胸中没有痞闷感,小便通畅自如。这是张仲景所说的“虚黄”。就用张仲景的方法治疗它。
诒按:此案明确用药恰当。
邓评:如此辨证,便觉得没有疑问。引用古方,也确实确切而不空泛。
湿气停滞,热气聚集,向上逆行则咽喉不利,向外显现则身体眼睛发黄,向下注注则小便红赤且疼痛。
诒按:论述病因能一线贯穿,用药自然丝丝入扣。
又按:咽喉不利,可以加桔梗、前胡之类的药。
痹气门
胸背属于阳的部位,痹阻不通,应当通其阳气,大概是因为阳气不能外行而郁结于中,则内部反而发热而外部反而发冷。通阳必须用辛温药,但辛温药又碍于脏气,打算用辛润药通肺来代替。
紫菀三两煎汤服用 诒按:这是巧妙的治法。只是不知道效果如何?
邓评:这似乎像《金匮要略》所论述的胸痹证,瓜蒌薤白半夏之类,能通阳而不碍脏气,摒弃不用,为什么呢?或者是单独使用这一味药,曾经试验过。
湿邪郁结遏制,阳气不宣发,外寒里热,胸满小便红赤。适宜开发上焦。
邓评:这是热郁结在内,肺气不宣发,所以只宜轻开上焦,不便因为外寒就投用姜、桂等热药。
气机窒塞不散,大便闭结气喘急促,不能仰卧,突然难以消散。
邓评:这一定是体质实、脉象实的病人,所以可以峻猛地使用开导药。大概是有见识的人自然能有胆量。
邓评:因为邪气已经化热,所以转换方剂改用寒下法。
胸中是阳的位置,阳气不布散,则窒塞不通。适宜温通,不宜清热,越用清热药则越窒塞。
诒按:再参入开痹的药物,如杏、菀、橘、桔等,似乎更灵动。
邓评:清阳所在的地方,纯被寒饮闭阻窒塞,自然不是温通不足以开其痹。
孙评:杏、菀、橘、桔,就是所说的越开越窒塞的情况。
进食后,胸背痞塞胀满,打嗝气不顺。这是阳气不通。适宜用辛通的方法。
邓评:饮邪阻滞气机郁结,阳络容易窒塞,辛通固然是必需的,像木香、砂仁疏畅中气的药物,还应当参入。
脘腹痛门
蛔厥心痛,痛时呕吐酸水,手脚冰凉。适宜用辛苦酸味的药物冶疗。
川黄连、桂枝、当归身、延胡索、乌梅、川椒、茯苓、川楝子、炮姜
邓评:方子与证候相符。只有蛔厥的确切依据,还有心下苦热,痛时攻冲触及有形之物,或者唇舌面色表现不定,大概是随着蛔虫的动静变化所致。
这是肾厥。心痛伴背部胀满,牵引到腰部。建议用许学士的香茸丸。
诒按:寒邪侵袭肾脏,而气机上逆,所以用温养法。胀满波及腰背,是督脉阳气不用的缘故。鹿茸温通督脉,麝香开泄浊阴,所以以它们为主药。
孙评:气从脐下上逆而厥,所以叫肾厥;四肢寒冷,所以用温养;背部重于胸部,所以用鹿茸、麝香。
脉弦小腹痛,饭后胃脘痛,上行至咽喉。肝火乘袭胃。适宜泄厥阴、和阳明。
邓评:病因饭后发作,是胃气被遏制而不通畅,与得食则缓解者有虚实之别,因此此方务必取疏泄之意。
孙评:肝火乘胃,由于痛时上行至咽喉的缘故,所以需要加黑栀子以清肝火。
诒按:立方稳妥符合。
瘕癖门
脐下有积块,摸上去发热,病人自觉子宫部位,前后二阴,都感觉热痛,可知是热结。况且以往的病,都出于肝脏。我的见解如果不泄厥阴,不能获得疗效。
龙荟丸五十粒酒送下
邓评:苦寒宣泄厥阴,恰好合病机,而且方内有麝香,能搜络散块。
络病瘀痹,左胁板硬坚实,前年用虫蚁药,通血升降开发已有效,但胸脘似是有形之物,按压微痛。前药太峻猛,现在用两调气血,以缓法图谋。
醋炒延胡索、姜黄、阿魏、桃仁、生香附、麝香、归须,研为末蜜丸,每服二钱
孙评:因为板硬坚实有形,所以用虫蚁搜血。比方略退一层,所以说缓法。
脉虚数,面色白无光泽。左胁有杯大的块,大小便通畅自如。病在肝脏,营血不和,此为虚中有实,补益必兼通利。
白术、当归身、炙甘草、白芍、生地、茯苓、琥珀、广陈皮、桃仁、红花、沉香、郁金
诒按:方治亲切不肤浅。
邓评:古人论治块有初中末三法,这就是中途的治法,但似乎可加用人参。
时病因饮食复发,至今不知饥饱,大便不爽,右胁旁,虚里天枢穴处,隐隐有形。这是阳明胃络循行的部位,多暖气不化,并不烦渴,难道是攻消急驱实热的证候吗?打算用丹溪的泄木安上法。
小温中丸 如果半月后有效仍以前法
诒按:这是中焦湿积阻结的证候。
左胁积块,日益增大,按压则痛,进食不安。凡是痞结之处,必有阳火郁伏于中,所以见烦躁口干心热等证。适宜用苦辛寒药,清之开之。然而这不是易事。
诒按:胁块有形益大,则营络必窒塞,似乎宜荣通才有效。
邓评:凡积块系久病体虚者,极难奏效。
方药稳妥切合,再参用金铃子散即可。
大腹右侧有形为聚,脉大,进食即作胀,治在六腑。
邓评:既然说脉大,为何不加川黄连、枳实?
心下高突,延及左胁有形,逐渐加重腹胀。考虑正月暴寒,口鼻吸入冷气,进入胃络膜原,清阳不用,浊阴凝阻,胃气重伤,有单腹病的累及,绝非小病。
另苏合香丸一粒化服。
邓评:高突有形,似乎宜兼通营络。
肿胀门
诒按:这是温中调气法。
邓评:这是因为中寒木郁,在温中方内,宜增白芍、金铃子、木瓜以平调其肝木。另外槟榔一味,不知取什么用意。
孙评:湿中生热,故术、柏并用。
脉微迟,左胁宿痞,腹部渐胀大,便溏尿少。这是浊阴上攻,当与通阳。
邓评:这是中虚湿热,兼有肝气内乘,方内附子易干姜为稳;远志不知从何取义?拟增白术、金铃子、青皮。
脾气本弱,而又受木克,克则更弱了,由此脾健失职,食入不消,遂生胀满;脾愈弱则肝愈强,时时攻逆,上下有声。半载之疾,年逾六旬,非旦夕可图也。
诒按:这是肝脾两治,而偏重于肝的,因为它不仅胀满,而且兼有攻逆之证。
邓评:案语辨理明晰,方意虚实兼到。
右关独大而搏指,知病在中焦,饮食不化,痞闷时痛,积年不愈,喉间自觉热气上冲,口干作苦,舌苔白燥。这是脾家积热郁湿。当以泻黄法治之。
诒按:这是痞满门中不常见的证候,存之以备一格。
邓评:右关独大,也是有肝木之火乘于中上的,盖不独积热使然。方法背谬,惟石膏究属不及川连为合度。
脉证合参,乃气结在上,津不运行,蒸变浊痰,由无形渐变有形。徐之才谓轻可去实,非胶固阴药所宜。
诒按:此方具有轻、清、灵三字之妙。
邓评:此病滋补阴药必已误服多矣,故立论如是。
劳郁交伤,营卫不和,胸中满痛,时有寒热。与六淫外感不同。治宜和养气血。
诒按:再增枳、朴等宽中之品,则更周到矣。
邓评:病虽非外感,而肝经亦有伏邪郁火。方法颇合,再增枳、朴理气,则更善矢。
脾以健运为职,心下痞不能食,食则满闷,脾失其职矣。但健运之品,迂缓无功,宜以补泻升降法治之。
胁下素有痞气,时时冲逆;今见中满,气攻作痛,吞酸呕吐,能俯而不能仰。这是厥阴郁滞之气,侵入太阴之分,得之多怒且善郁也。病久气弱,不任攻达;而病气久郁,亦难补养为掣肘耳。姑以平调肝胃之剂和之,痛定食进,方许万全。
诒按:审察病机,至为精细,立方亦周到熨帖。
不得已而立一平调郁气之方,亦限于时局如此。
孙评:议论透彻。
胃阳衰惫,气阻痰凝,中脘不快,食下则胀。适宜用辛温之品治之。
孙评:二症似乎相同,一则阳衰宜温,一则化热宜清。然温不用桂、附,非下焦阳衰也;热不用连、军,非结闭之甚也,同中有异,宜细参之。
腹胀、面浮、跗肿,食不下,欲呕。脾虚受湿,健运失常。非轻证也。
面黑,目黄,腹满,足肿,囊肿。湿热壅滞,从脾及肾,病深难治。
诒按:邪机壅滞,正气已伤,故云难治。
邓评:此等病明知正气已伤,也只得以驱导为法,为背城借一之计。
孙评:急泻其壅滞,以存其正,或可挽回。此则正气未致大伤者之法,另是一格。
卧则喘息有音,此肿胀,乃气壅于上。适宜用古人开鬼门之法,以治肺通表。
邓评:这是仲景成法,为的对之方。即使正气稍伤,仅以麻黄换苏子也可。
邓评:病似风水,立方不拘仲景成法,想因病势稍轻,或以正气受伤,贵乎随机应变者也。
肿胀之病,而二便如常,肢冷气喘。是非行气逐水之法所能愈者矣。当用肾气丸,行阳化水。然亦剧病也。
诒按:此病阳衰气窒,不治之证也。
头痛门
Malaria stops but recurs, with excessive sweating and vomiting; this is deficiency of the Middle Qi leading to rebellious Qi. It is appropriate to benefit the Yangming channel.
Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Poria (Fuling), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi), Ginseng Radix et Rhizoma (Renshen), Dendrobii Caulis (Shihu), Phragmitis Rhizoma (Lugen), Ginger Juice (Jiangzhi)
Comment by Deng: Observing the intention of this formula, there must be much phlegm-heat in the stomach.
Second visit: The chills and fever have stopped, and both sweating and vomiting have decreased. It is appropriate to harmonize and nourish Ying and Wei.
Ginseng Radix et Rhizoma (Renshen), Cinnamon Twig (Guizhi), Dendrobii Caulis (Shihu), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi), Angelicae Sinensis Radix (Guishen), Prepared Licorice Root (Zhigancao), Ophiopogonis Radix (Maidong), White Peony Root (Baishao)
Note by Yi: This is the treatment method for a deficient constitution caused by rich and greasy food. Both formulas are clear, steady, and appropriate.
Comment by Deng: Since the phlegm-heat has subsided, Ying and Wei appear even more deficient; hence, the formula is changed to specifically nourish Ying and Wei.
Jaundice Section
The face is dark and eyes yellow, pulse is rapid yet faint, feet are cold up to the knees, and skin and nails feel numb. The disease has penetrated into the Shaoyin channel, but the pathogenic factor originates from dampness due to white wine consumption and sexual exertion.
Kidney Qi Pill (Shenqi Wan)
Note by Yi: This case is recorded in *Jin Gui Yao Lue* (Essential Prescriptions from the Golden Cabinet). In recent times, it appeared in *Ailu Yian*, where one prescription was very good. This condition involves blood stasis in addition to dampness. Whether Shenqi Wan will be effective remains uncertain.
Comment by Deng: In this disease, Kidney Yang is indeed deficient, and Ying and Wei are naturally lacking, while damp-heat and blood stasis must also coexist. This formula seems to focus only on deficiency and fails to eliminate pathogens.
Comment by Sun: Jaundice accompanied by black discoloration due to blood stasis shares similar principles, providing another explanation.
Face, eyes, and body are all yellow, but there is no epigastric fullness or stuffiness, and urination is normal. This is what Zhang Zhongjing called "Deficiency Jaundice" (Xu Huang). Treat it using Zhang Zhongjing's method.
Cinnamon Twig (Guizhi), Astragalus Root (Huangqi), White Peony Root (Baishao), Poria (Fuling), Fresh Ginger (Shengjiang), Prepared Licorice Root (Zhigancao), Jujube (Dazao)
Note by Yi: The case clearly indicates appropriate medication.
Comment by Deng: With such accurate differentiation, there is no doubt. Quoting ancient formulas is precise and not superficial.
Comment by Sun: Zhang Zhongjing's method refers to Huangqi Jianzhong Tang.
Dampness stagnates and heat gathers; reversing upward causes throat discomfort; manifesting outwardly causes body and eye jaundice; sinking downward causes red and painful urination.
Artemisiae Scopariae Herba (Yinchen), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Fermented Soybean (Douchi), Akebia Caulis (Mutong), Polyporus (Zhuling), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Juhong), Poria (Fuling), Gardenia Fruit (Heizhi)
Note by Yi: The discussion of pathology is coherent throughout, so the medication is meticulously matched.
Additional Note: For throat discomfort, add Platycodon Root (Jiegeng) and Peucedani Radix (Qianhu).
Comment by Deng: This is steaming and flooding of damp-heat, classified as Yang Jaundice. The formula is light and elegant without flaws.
Bi-Qi Section
The chest and back belong to the Yang aspect. When Bi obstruction occurs and blocks flow, one should unblock Yang. Generally, if Yang cannot circulate outward and becomes stagnant internally, it leads to internal heat and external cold. Unblocking Yang requires acrid-warm herbs, but acrid-warm herbs may hinder Zang Qi. Therefore, it is proposed to use acrid-moist herbs to unblock the Lung instead.
Asterae Flos (Ziwan) 3 liang, decocted in water for oral administration. Note by Yi: This is a clever method. However, the efficacy is unknown.
Comment by Deng: This resembles the Chest Bi discussed in *Jin Gui Yao Lue*. Herbs like Trichosanthis Fructus (Gualou), Allii Macrostem (Xiebai), and Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia) can unblock Yang without hindering Zang Qi. Why were they excluded? Perhaps single herb therapy was tested previously.
Damp evil stagnates and obstructs, Yang Qi does not diffuse, presenting with external cold and internal heat, chest fullness, and red urine. It is appropriate to open and reach the Upper Jiao.
Asterae Flos (Ziwan), Platycodon Root (Jiegeng), Curcuma Aromatica Rhizome (Yujin), Amomi Fructus Rotundus (Baiko), Aurantii Fructus Immaturus (Zhike), Apricot Seed (Xingren), Fritillaria Bulb (Beimu), Licorice Root (Gancao)
Note by Yi: This is the standard method for treating Lung Bi.
Comment by Deng: Heat is stagnant internally, and Lung Qi is not diffusing. Thus, lightly opening the Upper Jiao is suitable; it is inappropriate to use warming herbs like Ginger (Jiang) and Cinnamon Twig (Guizhi) merely because of external cold.
Qi stagnation does not dissipate, bowel movement is closed, asthma is urgent, and lying flat is impossible; sudden dispersion is difficult.
Asterae Flos (Ziwan), Lepidii Semen (Tingli), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Apricot Seed (Xingren), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Juhong), Curcuma Aromatica Rhizome (Yujin), Aurantii Fructus Immaturus (Zhike)
Note by Yi: This condition is more urgent than the previous one, accompanied by constipation, so medication acts by draining and descending from the Middle Jiao.
Comment by Deng: This must be a patient with robust constitution and excess pulse, allowing for vigorous opening and guiding. One with insight naturally has courage.
Second visit: Rhubarb (Dahuang), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Areca Seed (Binglang), Aurantii Fructus Immaturus (Zhike), Apricot Seed (Xingren)
Note by Yi: Light agents were ineffective, so now we promote bowel movement to drain the Lung.
Comment by Deng: Since the pathogen has transformed into heat, the formula is changed to use cold purgation.
The chest is the seat of Yang. If Yang Qi does not distribute, obstruction and blockage occur. Warming and unblocking is appropriate; clearing heat is not. The more one clears, the more obstructed it becomes.
Cinnamon Twig (Guizhi), Poria (Fuling), Dried Ginger (Ganjiang), Prepared Licorice Root (Zhigancao), Alpinia Oxyphylla Fruit (Yizhiren)
Note by Yi: Adding opening-Bi herbs like Apricot Seed (Xingren), Asterae Flos (Ziwan), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Ju), and Platycodon Root (Jie) would seem more dynamic.
Comment by Deng: Where Clear Yang resides, if purely blocked by cold-fluid retention, only warming and unblocking can open the Bi.
Comment by Sun: Xingren, Ziwan, Ju, and Jie represent the situation where "the more one opens, the more obstructed it becomes."
After eating, chest and back feel stuffy and distended, with belching and discomfort. This is unblocked Yang Qi. Acrid-unblocking methods are appropriate.
Amomi Fructus (Caokouren), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Cinnamon Twig (Guizhi), Poria (Fuling), Dried Ginger (Ganjiang), Prepared Licorice Root (Zhigancao)
Note by Yi: This condition is similar to Chest Bi.
Comment by Deng: Fluid retention obstructs Qi stagnation, and Yang collaterals easily become blocked. Acrid-unblocking is essential. Herbs like Costus Root (Muxiang) and Amomum Fruit (Sharen) that smooth Middle Qi should also be included.
Epigastric and Abdominal Pain Section
Roundworm Jue causing heart pain, vomiting sour water during pain, and cold extremities. Bitter, acrid, and sour treatments are appropriate.
Coptis Rhizoma (Chuanlian), Cinnamon Twig (Guizhi), Angelicae Sinensis Radix (Guishen), Cyperi Rhizoma (Yanhu), Mume Fructus (Wumei), Zanthoxyli Fructus (Chuanjiao), Poria (Fuling), Toosendan Fructus (Chuandongzi), Prepared Ginger (Paojiang)
Note by Yi: This follows the method of Wumei Wan.
Comment by Deng: The formula matches the syndrome. However, definitive evidence of Roundworm Jue includes bitter heat in the epigastrium, pain attacking tangible structures, or fluctuating lip/tongue/face color, depending on the movement of roundworms.
This is Kidney Jue. Heart pain with back distension radiating to the waist. Propose using Xu Xueshi's Xiangrong Wan.
Deer Antler Glue (Lurong), Lycium Fruit (Qizi), Astragali Complanati Semen (Shayuan), Star Anise (Dahuixiang), Musk (Shexiang)
Note by Yi: Cold invades the Kidney, causing rebellious Qi, hence warm tonification is used. Distension involving waist and back indicates failure of Du Mai Yang. Deer Antler warms and unblocks Du Mai; Musk opens and drains turbid Yin, serving as chief herbs.
Comment by Deng: Consider adding Xuanfuhua Tang to unblock Ying collaterals.
Comment by Sun: Qi rebels upward from below the umbilicus causing Jue, thus named Kidney Jue; limbs are cold, hence warm tonification is used; back pain exceeds chest pain, hence Deer Antler and Musk are used.
String-like pulse, lower abdominal pain, epigastric pain after eating radiating to the throat. Liver Fire invading Stomach. Draining Jueyin and harmonizing Yangming is appropriate.
Toosendan Fructus (Chuandongzi), Akebia Caulis (Mutong), Poria (Fuling), Licorice Root (Gancao), Dendrobii Caulis (Shihu), Chaenomelis Fructus (Mu Gua)
Note by Yi: Suggest adding Cyperi Rhizoma (Yanhu) and Gardenia Fruit (Shanzhiren).
Comment by Deng: The cause is postprandial onset, indicating Stomach Qi is suppressed and not flowing smoothly, differing from cases relieved by eating (deficiency vs. excess). This formula aims at draining.
Comment by Sun: Liver Fire invading Stomach is evidenced by pain radiating to the throat; thus, Black Gardenia (Heizhi) should be added to clear Liver Fire.
Heart and abdominal pain, string-like pulse, blue complexion indicate Liver disease.
Toosendan Fructus (Chuandongzi), Angelicae Sinensis Radix (Guishen), Poria (Fuling), Dendrobii Caulis (Shihu), Cyperi Rhizoma (Yanhu), Chaenomelis Fructus (Mu Gua)
Note by Yi: The formula is stable and appropriate.
Comment by Deng: Differentiation is solid and unbiased, but acrid-unblocking herbs should be assisted in the formula.
Masses and Growths Section
Accumulation below the navel, hot to touch, patient feels heat and pain in uterus and both yin openings. Heat knot is evident. Moreover, past diseases often originate from the Liver. My view is that without draining Jueyin, efficacy cannot be achieved.
Longhui Wan 50 pills taken with wine.
Comment by Deng: Bitter-cold draining of Jueyin fits the pathology well. Additionally, Musk in the formula can search collaterals and disperse masses.
Comment by Sun: The pathology belongs to heat; the key lies in the sentence regarding heat and pain in the anterior and posterior yin openings.
Collateral disease with blood stasis and Bi, left hypochondrium is hard and solid. Last year, insect and ant herbs were used to regulate blood ascent and descent, showing some effect, but epigastrium feels somewhat tangible and slightly painful upon pressure. Previous herbs were too harsh. Now, balance Qi and Blood, using a slow approach.
Vine-processed Cyperi Rhizoma (Yanhu), Turmeric Rhizome (Jianghuang), Asafoetida (awei), Peach Kernel (Taoren), Raw Cyperi Tuber (Xiangfu), Musk (Shexiang), Angelicae Sinensis Radix Tip (Guixu), powder with honey pills, 2 qian per dose.
Note by Yi: Following the previous formula, although stated as balancing Qi and Blood, the main focus remains on dispersing stasis.
Comment by Deng: This adopts the strategy from the previous formula. For blood stasis masses, efficacy should be utilized.
Comment by Sun: Due to hardness and tangibility, insect herbs are used to search blood. Stepping back slightly from the previous formula explains the term "slow method."
Pulse is deficient and rapid, complexion is pale and lusterless. Left hypochondrium has a cup-sized mass, bowel and bladder movements are normal. Disease is in the Liver, Ying and Blood are disharmonious. This is deficiency with excess; tonification must include unblocking.
Atractylodes Macrocephala Rhizome (Baizhu), Angelicae Sinensis Radix (Guishen), Prepared Licorice Root (Zhigancao), White Peony Root (Baishao), Rehmanniae Radix (Shengdi), Poria (Fuling), Amber (Hupo), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi), Peach Kernel (Taoren), Safflower (Honghua), Agarwood (Chenxiang), Curcuma Aromatica Rhizome (Yujin)
Note by Yi: The treatment is intimate and not superficial.
Comment by Deng: Ancients discussed three stages for treating masses: early, middle, and late. This is the middle stage treatment, but Ginseng (Renshen) could potentially be added.
Seasonal illness relapsed due to diet, unaware of hunger or satiety, bowel movement is unsatisfactory, right hypochondrium, Xuli and Tianshu points show vague tangibility. This is the pathway of Yangming Stomach Collaterals. Frequent belching without transformation, no thirst or irritability. Is this a case requiring aggressive elimination of excess heat? Propose Danxi's method of draining Wood and calming Upper Jiao.
Xiaowenzhong Wan. If effective after half a month, continue with previous method.
Note by Yi: This is a case of Middle Jiao damp accumulation and obstruction.
Comment by Deng: Suspect phlegm-fluid obstructing Stomach collaterals; Chest Bi treatment methods might be borrowed.
Left hypochondrium mass increases daily, painful on pressure, uneasy after eating. Wherever痞结 (stuffiness and knotting) exists, Yang fire must be stagnant within, causing irritability, dry mouth, and heart heat. Bitter-acrid-cold herbs are needed to clear and open. However, this is not easy.
Coptis Rhizoma (Chuanlian), Immature Bitter Orange (Zhishi), Cyperi Tuber (Xiangfu), Ligusticum Rhizome (Chuanxiong), Medicated Leaven (Shenqu), Poria (Fuling), Green Tangerina Peel (Qingpi), Red Peony Root (Chishao)
Note by Yi: As the hypochondriac mass grows larger and tangible, Ying collaterals must be blocked; Ying-nourishing and unblocking seems necessary for efficacy.
Comment by Deng: Masses resulting from long-standing deficiency are extremely difficult to treat effectively.
Formula is stable and fitting; adding Jinlingzi San is advisable.
Comment by Sun: Possibly add Angelicae Sinensis Radix Tip (Guixu) and Jinlingzi San.
Right abdomen shows tangible accumulation, pulse is large, bloating immediately after eating. Treatment focuses on Six Fu organs.
Atractylodes Macrocephala Rhizome (Baizhu), Poria (Fuling), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi), Raw Cyperi Tuber Juice (Xiangfuzhi), Sparganium Rhizome (Sanleng), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Tsaoko Cardamom Fruit (Caoguo), Hawthorn Fruit (Shanzha)
Note by Yi: The formula mainly focuses on smoothing Qi mechanism.
Comment by Deng: Since pulse is large, why not add Coptis Rhizoma (Chuanlian) and Immature Bitter Orange (Zhishi)?
Epigastric region protrudes high, extending to left hypochondrium with tangibility, gradually worsening abdominal distension. Considering violent cold in January, cold air inhaled through mouth and nose entered Stomach collaterals and Mo Yuan. Clear Yang fails to function, turbid Yin condenses and obstructs, Stomach Qi is severely injured, leading to isolated abdominal distension. This is no minor ailment.
Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Tsaoko Cardamom Fruit (Caoguo), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Dried Ginger (Ganjiang), Poria (Fuling), Long Pepper Fruit (Bibo).
Separately, one Suhexiang Wan pill dissolved for administration.
Note by Yi: Cold evil closes Ying collaterals, hence warming and unblocking is used; Cinnamon Twig Tip (Guizhijian) could be added to the formula.
Comment by Deng: High protrusion with tangibility suggests combining Ying collateral unblocking.
Swelling and Distension Section
Pulse is slow, Stomach is cold, abdominal distension, Qi attacks chest and hypochondrium, nausea, poor appetite, diarrhea. Invigorating Spleen and Stomach Yang is appropriate.
Dried Ginger (Ganjiang), Alpinia Oxyphylla Fruit (Yizhiren), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Medicated Leaven (Shenqu), Areca Seed (Binglang), Zanthoxyli Fructus (Chuanjiao), Poria (Fuling)
Note by Yi: This is warming the Middle and regulating Qi method.
Comment by Deng: This arises from Middle Cold and Liver depression. Within the warming formula, add White Peony Root (Baishao), Jinlingzi, and Chaenomelis Fructus (Mu Gua) to peacefully regulate Liver Wood. Also, what is the purpose of Areca Seed (Binglang)?
Comment by Sun: Due to nausea and diarrhea, attention is focused on the Central Palace (Spleen/Stomach).
Mingmen Yang declines, Spleen loses warmth and nourishment, failing to transport and transform. Eating causes immediate distension. Method dictates warming and tonifying Lower Jiao.
Shenqi Wan minus Cinnamon Twig, add Agarwood (Chenxiang) and Sesamum Seed (Jiaomu).
Note by Yi: This is the method of tonifying Fire to generate Earth.
Comment by Deng: This is the gradual onset of isolated abdominal distension. The pill formula adjustments are worthy of study.
Damp-heat sinks into Taiyin causing distension.
Atractylodis Rhizoma (Maotou), Phellodendri Cortex (Chuanbai), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Chenpi, Mulberry Bark (Sangpi), Akebia Caulis (Mutong), Alisma Rhizome (Zexie), Betel Nut (Dafupi), Tsaoko Cardamom Fruit (Caoguoren).
Note by Yi: This specifically treats Spleen Earth damp-heat. Ancient formula Xiaowenzhong Wan can also be taken.
Comment by Deng: This condition must present with greasy-turbid tongue coating and scanty urine, indicating damp-heat excess syndrome, hence this method is used.
Comment by Sun: Heat generated from dampness, hence Atractylodes and Phellodendrum are used together.
Pulse is faint and slow, old痞 (mass/stuffiness) in left hypochondrium, abdomen gradually enlarges, loose stools, scanty urine. This is turbid Yin attacking upward; unblocking Yang is indicated.
Prepared Aconite Root (Shufuzi), Polygalae Radix (Yuanzhi), Sesamum Seed (Jiaomu), Small Fennel (Xiaohuixiang), Alisma Rhizome (Zexie), Poria (Fuling).
Note by Yi: This is the standard method for warming and unblocking to treat distension.
Comment by Deng: This is Middle deficiency with damp-heat, combined with Liver Qi invading internally. Replacing Aconite with Dried Ginger in the formula is steadier; the purpose of Polygalae Radix is unclear. Suggest adding Atractylodes Macrocephala Rhizome (Baizhu), Jinlingzi, and Green Tangerina Peel (Qingpi).
Spleen Qi is inherently weak, further suppressed by Wood. Suppression makes it weaker. Consequently, Spleen fails in its duty, food is not digested, leading to distension. The weaker the Spleen, the stronger the Liver, constantly attacking and rebelling, producing sounds above and below. Half-year illness, over sixty years old, cannot be resolved overnight.
Ginseng Radix et Rhizoma (Renshen), Poria (Fuling), Toosendan Fructus (Chuandongzi), Hawthorn Seed (Zhahe), Licorice Root (Gancao), Chaenomelis Fructus (Mu Gua), White Peony Root (Baishao), Evodia Fruit (Wuyu), Tangerine Seed (Juhe).
Note by Yi: This treats both Liver and Spleen, leaning towards Liver, because besides distension, there are attacking and rebellious symptoms.
Comment by Deng: Case notes clarify reasoning; formula addresses both deficiency and excess.
Comment by Sun: Mildly add Qi-regulating herbs like Magnolia Bark (Houpo) and Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi).
String-like pulse, central fullness, disease in Liver and Spleen.
Ginseng Radix et Rhizoma (Renshen), Evodia Fruit (Wuyu), Chaenomelis Fructus (Mu Gua), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia).
Note by Yi: This is the standard method for treating both Liver and Spleen. Formula is concise and worthy of study.
Comment by Deng: For string-like pulse, Baizhu is more appropriate than Renshen.
Right Guan pulse alone is large and beats against finger, indicating disease in Middle Jiao. Food not digested, stuffiness and intermittent pain, chronic for years, sensation of hot Qi rushing up throat, dry mouth with bitter taste, white dry tongue coating. This is Spleen accumulating heat and stagnating dampness. Xiehuang method should be used.
Atractylodis Rhizoma (Maotou), Puerariae Radix (Gegen), Poria (Fuling), Gypsum Fibrosum (Shigao), Pogostemonis Herba (Huoxiang), Costus Root (Muxiang).
Note by Yi: This is an uncommon case in the Stuffiness and Fullness section, preserved for reference.
Comment by Deng: Right Guan being large alone also indicates Liver Wood fire invading Middle and Upper, not just accumulated heat. The method deviates; however, Gypsum is still less suitable than Coptis Rhizoma (Chuanlian).
Comment by Sun: White dry tongue coating warrants Xiehuang method; if thick-dry coating and constipation exist, Chengqi formula can be used.
Pulse and symptoms combined indicate Qi knotting in Upper Jiao, fluids not circulating, steaming into turbid phlegm, changing from intangible to tangible. Xu Zhicai said "light can remove excess," not suitable for sticky Yin-tonifying herbs.
Amomi Fructus (Baokouren), Coicis Semen (Yiren), Apricot Seed (Xingren), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Loquat Leaf Juice (Pipayezhi), Jiangxiang Juice.
Note by Yi: This formula embodies the subtlety of "Light, Clear, and Agile."
Comment by Deng: This patient likely took Yin-tonifying herbs mistakenly for a long time, hence this argument.
Labor and Depression jointly injure, Ying and Wei disharmony, chest fullness and pain, occasional chills and fever. Different from Six Evils external contraction. Treatment should harmonize and nourish Qi and Blood.
Xiaoyao San.
Note by Yi: Adding Aurantii Fructus Immaturus (Zhi) and Magnolia Bark (Po) for widening Middle would be more comprehensive.
Comment by Deng: Although not external contraction, Liver channel has latent evil and stagnant fire. Method is quite fitting; adding Zhi and Po to regulate Qi would be better.
Comment by Sun: Chills and fever warrant use of Bupleuri Radix (Chaihu).
Spleen's function is transportation and transformation. Epigastric stuffiness prevents eating; eating causes fullness. Spleen has lost its function. But simple transporting herbs are slow and ineffective. Use tonifying-draining and ascending-descending methods.
Ginseng Radix et Rhizoma (Renshen), Dried Ginger (Ganjiang), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Poria (Fuling), Coptis Rhizoma (Chuanlian), Immature Bitter Orange (Zhishi), Chenpi, Fresh Ginger (Shengjiang).
Note by Yi: This formula imitates Xiexin method with additions.
Comment by Deng: This uses simultaneous tonifying and draining, bitter-draining and acrid-opening. "Ascending and Descending" terms seem forced.
Comment by Sun: Tonifying-draining and ascending-descending can assist transportation function; this is profound truth and innovative style.
Under hypochondrium, there is chronic痞气 (Qi stagnation/mass), occasionally rebelling; now central fullness, Qi attacks causing pain, acid regurgitation, vomiting, can bend forward but not lie back. This is Jueyin stagnant Qi invading Taiyin sector, caused by anger and depression. Long illness weakens Qi, unable to withstand strong attacking/draining; long-stagnated pathogenic Qi is also hard to tonify. Temporarily use harmonizing formula to balance Liver and Stomach. Only when pain settles and appetite improves can safety be guaranteed.
Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi), Toosendan Fructus (Chuandongzi), Tangerine Seed (Juhe), Poria (Fuling), Green Tangerina Peel (Qingpi), Prepared Licorice Root (Zhigancao), Chaenomelis Fructus (Mu Gua).
Note by Yi: Pathogenesis analysis is extremely detailed; formula construction is thorough and appropriate.
Comment by Deng: With acid regurgitation evidence, although deficient, tonification is contraindicated.
Forced to create a formula for peacefully regulating stagnant Qi, limited by current situation.
Comment by Sun: Discussion is thorough.
Stomach Yang declines and exhausts, Qi obstructs, phlegm condenses, epigastrium uncomfortable, bloating after eating. Acrid-warm herbs are appropriate.
Tsaoko Cardamom Fruit (Caoguoren), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Poria (Fuling), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Licorice Root (Gancao), Areca Seed (Binglang).
Note by Yi: This is damp-phlegm obstructing Middle Palace.
Comment by Deng: Based on herbs, Stomach Yang decline might still be manageable.
Heat knot and Qi closure, abdominal distension, difficult defecation.
Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Apricot Seed (Xingren), Talcum (Huashi), Scutellaria Root (Huangqin), Betel Nut (Dafupi), Pepo Skin (Fulingpi), Akebia Caulis (Mutong).
Note by Yi: This is regulating Middle while draining heat.
Comment by Deng: Add Aurantii Fructus Immaturus (Zhike) and Benincasae Exocarpium (Loupi) to unblock bowels.
Comment by Sun: Two symptoms seem similar, one requires warming for Yang decline, one requires clearing for heat transformation. However, warming without Guizhi/Fuzi means not Lower Jiao Yang decline; clearing without Lianjun/Jun means not severe knot/closure. Similarities contain differences; careful consideration is needed.
Abdominal distension, facial edema, foot swelling, inability to eat, desire to vomit. Spleen deficiency receiving dampness, transportation失常 (abnormal). Not a mild case.
Atractylodis Rhizoma (Maotou), Poria (Fuling), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Guangpi), Mulberry Bark (Sangpi), Akebia Caulis (Mutong), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Alisma Rhizome (Zexie), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Polyporus (Zhuling).
Note by Yi: This is regulating Middle and promoting dampness drainage.
Comment by Deng: Foot swelling mostly relates to Yang deficiency. Formula seems lacking Yang-unblocking herbs.
Dark face, yellow eyes, abdominal fullness, leg swelling, scrotal swelling. Damp-heat congestion, spreading from Spleen to Kidney, deep disease, difficult to treat.
Atractylodis Rhizoma (Cangzhu), Prepared Rhubarb (Zhi Jun), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Chenpi, Akebia Caulis (Mutong), Artemisiae Scopariae Herba (Yinchen), Polyporus (Zhuling), Sesamum Seed (Jiaomu), Alisma Rhizome (Zexie).
Note by Yi: Pathogenic mechanism congested, healthy Qi already injured, hence difficult to treat.
Comment by Deng: Knowing healthy Qi is injured in such diseases, only driving and guiding methods remain, a last-resort plan.
Comment by Sun: Urgently drain congestion to preserve healthy Qi, possibly reversible. This is a method for cases where healthy Qi is not severely damaged, a different category.
Wheezing with sound when lying down, this swelling is Qi congestion in Upper Jiao. Ancient method "Open Ghost Gate" (sweating) should be used to treat Lung and unblock exterior.
Ephedrae Herba (Mahuang), Apricot Seed (Xingren), Coicis Semen (Yiren), Licorice Root (Gancao).
Note by Yi: Accompanied by wheezing/reversal, hence specifically treating Lung.
Comment by Deng: This is Zhang Zhongjing's established method, a targeted formula. Even if healthy Qi is slightly injured, replacing Mahuang with Perillae Fructus (Suzi) suffices.
Wind-Dampness combats, facial edema, abdominal fullness and swelling, difficulty in urination and defecation.
Apricot Seed (Xingren), Perillae Fructus (Suzi), Magnolia Bark (Houpo), Chenpi, Polyporus (Zhuling), Betel Nut (Dafupi), Ginger Skin (Jiangpi), Akebia Caulis (Mutong).
Note by Yi: This is simultaneous interior-exterior unblocking.
Comment by Deng: Disease resembles Fengshui, formula does not strictly follow Zhang Zhongjing's methods, likely due to milder progression or injured healthy Qi, emphasizing adaptability.
Swelling disease, but urination and defecation normal, cold limbs, asthma. Methods of moving Qi and purging water cannot cure this. Shenqi Wan should be used to move Yang and transform water. However, this is also a severe disease.
Shenqi Wan.
Note by Yi: This disease features Yang decline and Qi obstruction, considered incurable.
Comment by Deng: Disease is undoubtedly Kidney deficiency and Yang decline. Large dose decoction might save critical illness.
Headache Section
Fire rises, headache, tinnitus, epigastric stuffiness, occurring immediately after meals. This is Phlegm-Fire intertwining in Yangming and Shaoyang channels, exacerbated by food Qi, different from Yin-deficiency Fire flaming. First clear and regulate, then tonify and descend.
Bambusa Textilis Spathe (Zhuru), Poria (Fuling), Exocarpium Citri Reticulatae (Juhong), Prepared Licorice Root (Zhigancao), Pinellia Rhizoma (Banxia), Antelope Cornu (Lingyangjiao), Dendrobii Caulis (Shihu), Uncaria Rhynchophylla (Goutenggou)