六十九难曰∶经言虚者补之,实者泻之,不虚不实,以经取之,何谓也?
然∶虚者补其母,实
者泻其子,当先补之,然后泻之。不虚不实,以经取之者,是正经自生病,不中他邪也,当自取其
经,故言以经取之。
经言,《灵枢·经脉篇》也。虚,血气虚也。实,血气实也。补之,行针用补法也。泻之,
行针用泻法也。以经取之,言循其本经所宜刺之穴也。母,生我者也。子,我生者也。经脉篇
载十二经,皆有盛则泻之,虚则补之,不盛不虚,以经取之,虚者补其母,实者泻其子。盖子
能令母实,母能令子虚也。假令肝病虚,则补其母合,即足厥阴之合曲泉穴是也。肝病实,则
泻其子荥,即足厥阴之荥行间穴是也。当先补之,然后泻之两句,滑氏谓即后篇阳气不足,阴
气有余,当先补其阳,而后泻其阴之意。然于此义不属,非误即羡文也。若忧愁思虑则伤心,
形寒饮冷则伤肺,恚怒气逆则伤肝,饮食劳倦则伤脾,久坐湿地,强力入水则伤肾。正经自病,
非五邪所伤者,即于本经取当刺之穴以刺之,不必补母泻子也。
七十难曰∶经言春夏刺浅,秋冬刺深者。何谓也?
然∶春夏者,阳气在上,人气亦在上,故当
浅取之;秋冬者,阳气在下,人气亦在下,故当深取之。
《灵枢·终始篇》曰∶春气在毛,夏气在皮肤,秋气在分肉,冬气在筋骨,此四时之气也。其
四时受病,亦各随正气之浅深,故用针以治病者,各根据四时气之浅深而取之也。阳气者,谓天
地之气也;人气者,谓营卫之气也。上言皮肉之上,下言筋骨之中,浅取深取,必中其病也。
滑氏曰∶春夏之时,阳气浮而上,人气亦然,故刺之当浅,欲其无太过也;秋冬之时,阳气沉
而下,人气亦然,故刺之当深,欲其无不及也。经曰∶必先岁气,无伐天和,此之谓也。
春夏各致一阴,秋冬各致一阳者,何谓也?
然∶春夏温,必致一阴者,初下针,沉之至肾肝之
部,得气,引持之阴也。秋冬寒,必致一阳者,初内针,浅而浮之至心肺之部,得气,推内之阳
也。是谓春夏必致一阴,秋冬必致一阳。
致,取也,温,时令温也。寒,时令寒也。经言春夏养阳者,阳盛则阴不足,必取一阴之气
以养阳也。秋冬养阴者,阴盛则阳不足,必取一阳之气以养阴也。沉之,深入其针至肾肝之位,
引其阴气,出之于阳也。浮之,谓浅内其针至心肺皮血之位,推其阳气,入之于阴也。
按∶滑氏曰∶春夏气温,必致一阴者,春夏养阳之义也。初下针,即沉之至肾肝之部,俟其
得气,乃引针而提之,以至于心肺之分,所谓致一阴也。秋冬气寒,必致一阳者,秋冬养阴之
义也。初内针,浅而浮之,当心肺之部,俟其得气,推针而内之,以达于肾肝之分,所谓致一
阳也。然致阴致阳之说,越人特推其理有如是者耳。凡用针补泻,自有所宜,初不必以是相拘也。
第六十九难说:医经中说,虚证用补法,实证用泻法,不虚不实的病证,则取本经穴位治疗。这是什么意思呢?
回答说:虚证要补其母穴,实证要泻其子穴。应当先补后泻。所谓不虚不实,取本经穴位治疗,是指本经自身发病,没有受到其他邪气侵袭,因此直接取用本经的穴位,所以说“以经取之”。
这里所说的“经”,指的是《灵枢·经脉篇》。虚,是指血气虚弱;实,是指血气壅盛。补,是指行针时使用补法;泻,是指行针时使用泻法。以经取之,意思是沿着本经适宜针刺的穴位进行针刺。母,指生我者(五行中生成我的元素);子,指我生者(五行中我所生的元素)。《经脉篇》记载十二经脉,都有盛则泻之、虚则补之、不盛不虚则以经取之的原则,以及虚者补其母、实者泻其子的原则。这是因为子能令母实,母能令子虚。例如,肝虚证,则补其母穴合穴,即足厥阴肝经的合穴曲泉穴。肝实证,则泻其子穴荥穴,即足厥阴肝经的荥穴行间穴。“当先补之,然后泻之”这两句话,滑寿先生认为是指后文中阳气不足、阴气有余时,应当先补阳而后泻阴的意思。但这与这里的文义不符,要么是错误,要么是衍文。如果是忧愁思虑则伤心,形体受寒或饮食生冷则伤肺,愤怒气逆则伤肝,饮食不节或过度劳累则伤脾,久坐湿地或强力涉水则伤肾。这些属于正经自病,不是被五邪所伤,就在本经选取应当针刺的穴位来刺,不需要采用补母泻子的方法。
第七十难说:医经中说,春夏季节针刺宜浅,秋冬季节针刺宜深。这是什么意思呢?
回答说:春夏时节,阳气上升于体表,人体的气血也运行于体表,所以应当浅刺;秋冬时节,阳气下沉于体内,人体的气血也沉伏于体内,所以应当深刺。
《灵枢·终始篇》说:春气在毫毛,夏气在皮肤,秋气在分肉,冬气在筋骨,这是四时的气候特点。人体在这四个季节患病,也是随着正气所在的深浅不同而各异,所以用针刺治病的人,各根据四时之气所在的深浅来选择针刺部位。所谓的“阳气”,是指天地的气候之气;“人气”,是指人体内的营卫之气。上文说的“上”指皮肉之上,下文说的“下”指筋骨之中,浅刺和深刺,必须准确针对病位。
滑寿先生说:春夏之时,阳气浮越向上,人气也随之向上,所以针刺应当浅,目的是防止太过;秋冬之时,阳气沉降向下,人气也随之向下,所以针刺应当深,目的是防止不及。医经说:“必须先顺应岁气,不要破坏天和之气”,说的就是这个道理。
春夏各致一阴,秋冬各致一阳,这是什么意思呢?
回答说:春夏气温温暖,必须“致一阴”,即初下针时,将针深入至肾肝所在的深层部位,得气后,牵引持守其阴气。秋冬气候寒冷,必须“致一阳”,即初进针时,浅刺并提引至心肺所在的浅层部位,得气后,推进内纳其阳气。这就叫做春夏必致一阴,秋冬必致一阳。
“致”,意为取用;“温”,指时令温暖;“寒”,指时令寒冷。医经说春夏养阳,是因为阳盛则阴不足,必须取用一阴之气来涵养阳;秋冬养阴,是因为阴盛则阳不足,必须取用一阳之气来涵养阴。所谓“沉之”,是将针深入至肾肝之位,引导阴气出于阳分;所谓“浮之”,是将针浅入至心肺皮血之位,推引阳气入于阴分。
按语:滑寿先生说:春夏气温温暖,必须致一阴,这是春夏养阳的含义。初下针时,即沉针至肾肝之部,等到得气后,再引针提起,至于心肺之分,这就是所谓的致一阴。秋冬气候寒冷,必须致一阳,这是秋冬养阴的含义。初进针时,浅刺浮取,当于心肺之部,等到得气后,推针深入,以达到肾肝之分,这就是所谓的致一阳。然而,关于致阴致阳的说法,是越人(秦越人/扁鹊)特别推演其原理如此罢了。凡是用针进行补泻,自有其适宜的法则,起初不必被这种说法所拘束。
Chapter 69 states: The classics say, "Tonify deficiency, sedate excess, and for neither-deficient-nor-excess conditions, treat via the affected meridian." What does this mean?
The response is: For deficiency, tonify its mother; for excess, sedate its child. One should first tonify, then sedate. Regarding "neither-deficient-nor-excess conditions, treat via the affected meridian," this refers to a disease originating from the regular meridian itself, without invasion by other pathogenic factors. Therefore, one should directly select points from that specific meridian, hence the phrase "treat via the affected meridian."
The term "classics" here refers to the *Ling Shu · Jing Mai* (Spiritual Pivot · Meridians) chapter. "Deficiency" refers to the deficiency of blood and qi; "excess" refers to the abundance of blood and qi. "Tonify" means applying the tonification method during needle manipulation; "sedate" means applying the sedation method. "Treat via the affected meridian" implies selecting and needling points appropriate to the primary meridian involved. "Mother" refers to that which generates me (in the Five Elements theory); "child" refers to that which I generate. The *Jing Mai* chapter records that all twelve meridians follow the principles: "Sedate when excessive, tonify when deficient, and treat via the meridian when neither excessive nor deficient," as well as "Tonify the mother in deficiency, sedate the child in excess." This is because the child can cause the mother to become full, and the mother can cause the child to become empty. For example, in liver deficiency, one would tonify its mother's He-Sea point, which is Ququan (LR 3), the He-Sea point of the Foot Jueyin Liver Meridian. In liver excess, one would sedate its child's Ying-Spring point, which is Xingjian (LR 2), the Ying-Spring point of the Foot Jueyin Liver Meridian. The two sentences "first tonify, then sedate" are interpreted by Master Hua (Shou) as referring to the later passage stating that when yang qi is insufficient and yin qi is excessive, one should first tonify yang and then sedate yin. However, this interpretation does not fit the context here; it is either an error or an interpolated text. If sorrow and worry injure the heart, cold form and cold drinks injure the lungs, anger and qi rebellion injure the liver, improper diet and fatigue injure the spleen, and sitting long in damp places or forcing entry into water injures the kidneys—these constitute diseases arising from the regular meridians themselves, not injuries from the five pathogenic factors. In such cases, one selects the appropriate points on the primary meridian for needling, without needing to employ the methods of tonifying the mother or sedating the child.
Chapter 70 states: The classics say, "In spring and summer, needle shallowly; in autumn and winter, needle deeply." What does this mean?
The response is: In spring and summer, yang qi ascends to the exterior, and human qi also resides at the exterior; therefore, one should needle shallowly. In autumn and winter, yang qi sinks to the interior, and human qi also resides in the interior; therefore, one should needle deeply.
The *Ling Shu · Zhong Shi* (Spiritual Pivot · Beginning and End) chapter says: "Spring qi is in the hair follicles, summer qi is in the skin, autumn qi is in the muscle layers, and winter qi is in the sinews and bones; these are the characteristics of the four seasons' qi." Diseases contracted during these four seasons vary according to the depth of the healthy qi; thus, practitioners using acupuncture to treat diseases should select depths based on the seasonal distribution of qi. By "yang qi," we refer to the climatic qi of heaven and earth; by "human qi," we refer to theying and wei qi within the body. The "upper" mentioned above refers to the superficial layers of skin and flesh, while the "lower" below refers to the deeper layers of sinews and bones. Shallow or deep needling must accurately target the pathological site.
Master Hua states: During spring and summer, yang qi floats upward, and human qi follows suit; thus, needling should be shallow to prevent excess. During autumn and winter, yang qi sinks downward, and human qi follows suit; thus, needling should be deep to prevent insufficiency. The classic says, "First conform to the annual climate, do not violate the harmony of nature," which refers to this principle.
What is meant by "in spring and summer, each draws forth one yin; in autumn and winter, each draws forth one yang"?
The response is: Spring and summer are warm; one must "draw forth one yin." Initially inserting the needle, sink it deeply to the regions of the kidney and liver. Upon obtaining deqi (needle sensation), guide and hold the yin qi. Autumn and winter are cold; one must "draw forth one yang." Initially inserting the needle, place it shallowly and lift it to the regions of the heart and lung. Upon obtaining deqi, push and insert the yang qi. This is called "drawing forth one yin in spring and summer" and "drawing forth one yang in autumn and winter."
"Draw forth" means to obtain or utilize. "Warm" refers to the warm seasonal climate; "cold" refers to the cold seasonal climate. The classic states that in spring and summer, one nourishes yang; since yang is abundant, yin may be insufficient, so one must obtain yin qi to nourish yang. In autumn and winter, one nourishes yin; since yin is abundant, yang may be insufficient, so one must obtain yang qi to nourish yin. "Sinking" (chen) means inserting the needle deeply to the positions of the kidney and liver to draw yin qi out to the yang level. "Floating" (fu) means inserting the needle shallowly to the positions of the heart, lung, skin, and blood to push yang qi into the yin level.
Commentary: Master Hua states: The warmth of spring and summer requires drawing forth one yin, which embodies the principle of nourishing yang in spring and summer. Initially inserting the needle, sink it to the kidney and liver regions. Wait for deqi, then lift the needle to the heart and lung levels; this is what is meant by drawing forth one yin. The cold of autumn and winter requires drawing forth one yang, embodying the principle of nourishing yin in autumn and winter. Initially inserting the needle, place it shallowly in the heart and lung regions. Wait for deqi, then push the needle deeply to the kidney and liver levels; this is what is meant by drawing forth one yang. However, the theory of drawing forth yin and yang is merely Yu Ren (Bian Que) deducing the rationale behind such practices. In actual acupuncture tonification and sedation, there are appropriate methods inherent to the condition; one need not be strictly bound by this specific theory.