之此活法也与食则咽者邪不在胃也不与则不思者以其神昏故也热邪既不在胃误与承气汤下之其死也必矣按伤寒本只传
足经以上又例传手经之义可谓发病机之秘矣盖只是邪蕴日久因足经实手经虚故冤热耳有因汗下差误而传有因七情或劳
倦等而致者有之大抵传手经必有所因所以古人有救逆复脉等法岂但切中病情实启后人之义例耳
凡伤寒之病多从风寒得之始表中风寒入里则不消矣未有温覆而当不消散者不在证治拟欲攻之犹当先解表乃可下之
若表已解而内不消非大满犹生寒热则病不除若表已解而内不消大满大实坚有燥屎自可除下之虽四五日不能为祸也若不
宜下而便攻之内虚热入协热遂利烦躁诸变不可胜数轻者困笃重者必死矣夫阳盛阴虚汗之则死下之则愈阳虚阴盛汗之则
愈下之则死夫如是则神丹安可以误发甘遂何可以妄攻虚盛之治相背千里吉凶之机应若影响岂容易哉况桂枝下咽阳盛即
毙承气入胃阴盛以亡死生之要在乎须臾视身之尽不暇计日此阴阳虚实之交错其候至微发汗吐下之相反其祸至速而医术
浅狭懵然不知病源为治乃误使病者殒没自谓其分至令冤魂塞于冥路死尸盈于旷野仁者鉴此岂不痛欤凡两感病俱作治有
先后发表攻里本自不同而执迷用意者乃云神丹甘遂合而饮之且解其表又除其里言虽巧似其理实违夫智者之举错适成夫
愚者之动作也设此法必果而速安危之变岂可诡哉世上之士但务彼俗习之荣而莫见此倾危之败惟明者居然能护其本近取
诸身夫何远之有焉凡发汗温服汤药其方虽言日三服若病剧不解当促其间可半日中尽三服若与病相阻即便有所觉病重者
一日一夜当 时观之如服一剂病证犹在故当复作本汤服之至有不肯汗出服三剂乃解若汗不出者死病也服桂枝汤大汗出
脉洪大者复与桂枝汤如前法发汗解半日许复烦脉浮数者可更发汗(活人云乙发汗病证仍在者三日内可二三汗之令腰以下
周遍为度按此等处极要精审不可孟浪)凡服汤药发汗中病即止不必尽剂吐下亦如之
许 记一乡人伤寒身热大便不通烦渴郁冒医者用巴豆下之顷得溏利病宛然如旧予观之阳明结热在里非大柴胡承气
不可巴豆止去积不能荡涤邪热蕴毒亟进大柴胡等三服得汗而解尝谓仲景一百一十三方为丸者有五理中陷胸抵当乌梅麻
仁是以理中陷胸抵当皆大如弹子煮化而服与汤散无异至于麻仁治脾约乌梅治湿 皆用小丸以达下部其他逐邪毒破坚癖
导瘀血润燥粪之类皆凭汤剂未闻用巴豆小丸药以下邪气也既下而病不除不免重以大黄芒硝下之安能无损也哉
凡病若发汗若吐若下若亡津液阴阳自和者必自愈(重亡津液则不能作汗故必待自和乃愈)太阳病三日已发汗若吐若
下若温针仍不解者此为坏证桂枝不中与也观其脉证知犯何逆随证治之
活 未满三日可汗而已满三日者可泄而已此大略言之耳凡病患有虚有实邪气传受迟速不同岂可拘以日数仲景云日
数虽多但有表证而脉浮者犹宜发汗日数虽少若有里证而脉沉者即宜下之正应随脉治之又况六气之邪乘虚入经如自背得
之则入太阳或入少阴自面感之则入阳明之类不必皆始于太阳也兼寒邪有首尾止在一经或间传一二经不可以一理推但视
脉与外证治之此活法也假令有人脉浮头项强痛发热而恶寒每日如此不以日数多少正是太阳经受之其余经皆仿此大抵伤
寒惟凭脉与外证以汗下之若过日多脉尚大浮数按之不足者尚责太阳也可发汗而愈若按之实者汗之必死须下之而愈也若
始病脉沉细数外证或腹满咽干或口燥舌干而渴为热正责属里可下之而愈若无此证表热脉沉误下者必死须用麻黄附子甘
草汤麻黄细辛附子汤少发汗以治之此皆仲景之确论也
戴 伤寒要紧处在分表里而为汗下有病患自汗自下者有医用药汗之下之者中间节目颇多汗药宜早下药宜迟此亦大
纲之论耳且如失血家不可发汗淋家不可发汗如此等类岂宜遽用表剂当徐徐解散苟或不当汗而强汗则津液耗竭变生百病
因兹夭伤岂可一以汗药宜早为说阳明汗出而多宜急下少阴下利而渴宜急下厥阴舌卷囊缩宜急下如此等证当用速利之剂
苟或当下而不下则热毒转深遂致失下不可救疗岂可一以下药宜迟为说
洁 伤寒之法先言表里及有缓急三阳表当急里当缓三阴表当缓里当急又曰脉浮当汗脉沉当下脉浮汗急而下缓谓三
阳表也脉沉下急而汗缓谓三阴里也麻黄汤谓之急麻黄附子细辛汤谓之缓内经云有渍形以为汗谓汗之缓里之表也又云在
皮者汗而发之谓汗之急表之表也急汗者太阳缓汗者少阴是脏腑之输应也假令附子麻黄细辛汤是少阴证始得发热脉沉里
和无汗故渍形为汗今麻黄汤是太阳证头项痛腰脊强脉浮无汗里和是也在皮者汗而发之可也经曰治主以缓治客以急此之
谓也(麻黄汤方见太阳病)
假令得肝脉其外证善洁面青善怒其三部脉俱弦而浮恶寒里和清便自调麻黄汤内加羌活防风各三钱谓肝主风是胆经
受病也大便秘或泄下赤水无数皆里不和也假令得心脉其外证面赤口干善笑其尺寸脉俱浮而洪恶寒里和清便自调麻黄汤
内加黄芩石膏各三钱谓心主热是小肠受病也假令得脾脉其外证面黄善噫善思善味尺寸脉俱浮而缓里和恶寒麻黄汤内加
白术防风各三钱谓脾主湿是胃经受病也假令得肺脉其外证面白善嚏悲愁不乐欲哭其尺寸脉俱浮而涩里和恶寒麻黄汤内
加桂枝生姜各三钱谓肺主燥是大肠受病也假令得肾脉其外证面黑善恐欠尺寸脉俱沉而里和恶寒麻黄汤内加附子生姜各
三钱谓肾主寒是膀胱受病也
以上五证皆表之表也谓在皮者急汗而发之皆腑受病也表之里者下之当缓谓随脏表证外显尺寸脉俱浮而复有里证谓
发热饮水便利赤色或泄下赤水其脉浮按之内实或痛麻黄汤方去麻黄杏仁随脏元加药同煎分作五服每下一证初一服加大
黄五分如邪未尽又加大黄一钱未尽再加大黄一钱半直候邪尽则止此先缓而后急是表之里宜下之当缓也
假令得肝脉其内证满闷淋沥便难转筋其尺寸脉俱沉而弦里和恶寒肝经受病麻黄附子细辛汤内加羌活防风各三钱假
令得心脉其内证烦心心痛掌中热而哕其尺寸脉俱沉洪里和恶寒心经受病于前汤内加黄芩石膏各三钱假令得脾脉其内证
腹满胀食不消怠惰嗜卧其尺寸脉俱沉缓里和恶寒肺经受病加白术防己各三钱假令得肺脉其内证喘嗽洒淅寒热其尺寸脉
俱沉涩里和恶寒肺经受病加生姜桂枝各三钱假令得肾脉其内证泄泻下重足胫寒而逆其尺寸脉俱沉里和恶寒此肾经受病
加姜附各三钱
以上五证里之表也宜清形以为汗皆脏受病也里之里者下之当急谓随脏内证已显尺寸脉俱沉而复有里证谓小便赤大
便秘涩或泻下赤水或泻或咳不能饮食不恶风寒发热引饮其脉俱沉按之内实而痛此谓里实宜速下之麻黄附子细辛汤内去
麻黄随脏元加药同煮分作三服每下一证初一服加大黄三钱邪尽即止如邪未尽第二服加大黄二钱又未尽第三服加大黄一
钱此先急而后缓是里之里也宜速下之
这是治疗伤寒的灵活方法。如果进食时吞咽困难,说明邪气不在胃;如果不进食是因为神志昏沉,也是同样的道理。热邪既然不在胃,误用承气汤攻下,患者必然死亡。
按照《伤寒论》的理论,病邪本来只传变于足经,以上述例子类推手经传变的含义,可以说是揭示了发病机理的奥秘。这大概是因为邪气蕴结日久,导致足经实而手经虚,从而产生冤热(郁热)。有的因为汗法或下法使用不当而传变,有的因为七情内伤或劳倦等因素引起。大抵上传变到手经必定有其原因,所以古人制定了救逆、复脉等治疗方法,这不仅切中病情,也开启了后人的义例法则。
凡是伤寒病,多从风寒之邪得来,起初在表,若风寒入里则无法自行消散。没有温覆得当而不能消散的情况。不在证治阶段,想要攻下,应当先解表,然后才可以攻下。如果表证已解但体内积滞未消,如果不是大满实证,仍然会产生寒热,疾病就不能消除。如果表证已解且体内积滞未消,出现大满、大实、坚硬且有燥屎的情况,自然可以攻下。即使病程已有四五日,也不会造成祸害。如果不适宜攻下却强行攻下,会导致内部虚弱,热邪内陷,伴随发热而下利,烦躁等各种变证不可胜数。轻者病情加重,重者必然死亡。
阳气盛而阴气虚,发汗则死,攻下则愈;阳气虚而阴气盛,发汗则愈,攻下则死。像这样,神丹(指发汗峻剂)怎么可以误用发汗?甘遂(逐水药)怎么可以妄用攻下?虚证和实证的治法相反,吉凶的差异如同千里之遥,生死的关键就在顷刻之间,视察全身情况尚且来不及,哪有时间去计算日子呢?况且桂枝汤服下,若阳盛即毙命;承气汤入胃,若阴盛则亡身。死生的关键在乎须臾之间,观察病人全身状况尚且来不及,哪有空闲去计算天数?这是阴阳虚实交错的情况,其征候极其细微,发汗、吐法、下法如果用反了,灾祸发生极快。医术浅陋的人,懵懂不知病源,治疗失误,致使病人死亡,还自以为合乎分理,直到令冤魂塞满冥路,死尸堆满旷野。仁人君子鉴于此,难道不痛心吗?
凡是两感病(表里同病),治疗有先后之分,发表和攻里本不相同。但那些执迷不悟的人,竟然说将神丹和甘遂混合饮用,既能解表又能除里。言辞虽然巧妙,但道理实则违背常理。智者的举动,恰恰成就了愚者的行为。假如这种方法真的能迅速决定安危的变化,怎么可能如此诡异呢?世上的人只追求世俗习气的荣耀,而看不到这种倾覆危险的败局。只有明智的人能够独自守护根本,就近取譬于自身,何必远求呢?
凡是发汗,温服汤药,方子虽然说是每日三服,但如果病情严重不解,应当缩短服药间隔,可以在半天之内服完三服。如果与病情相抵触,即便有所察觉,病情重的,一天一夜应当随时观察。如果服用一剂后病证仍在,就应当继续服用原汤药。甚至有不肯出汗,服用三剂后才解除的。如果不出汗,是死证。服用桂枝汤大汗出,脉象洪大的,再次给予桂枝汤,按前法发汗。解表约半日后,又出现烦渴,脉浮数的,可以再次发汗。(《活人书》说:发汗后病证仍在的,三日内可以发汗二三次,以腰部以下周身遍身为度。按:这些情况极其需要精审,不可鲁莽。)凡是服用汤药发汗,中病(见效)就停止,不必服完全部药剂。吐法和下法也是如此。
许学士记载:有一个乡人患伤寒,身体发热,大便不通,烦渴,头目昏眩。医生用巴豆攻下,不久得到溏泄,病势依然如旧。我观察他,是阳明结热在里,非大柴胡汤或承气汤不可。巴豆只能去除积滞,不能荡涤邪热蕴毒。于是急进大柴胡汤等,服用三剂后得汗而解。我曾说张仲景的一百一十三方中,制成丸剂的只有五种:理中丸、陷胸丸、抵当丸、乌梅丸、麻仁丸。其中理中、陷胸、抵当都做成弹子大小,煮化后服用,与汤散无异。至于麻仁丸治脾约,乌梅丸治湿痢,都用小丸以达到下部。其他驱逐邪毒、破坚癖、导瘀血、润燥粪之类的,都凭借汤剂,没听说过用小丸药来下邪气的。既然已经攻下而病不除,不免再用大黄、芒硝攻下,怎么能不损伤正气呢?
凡是疾病,如果经过发汗、催吐、攻下,或者津液亡失,只要阴阳能够自我调和,必定自愈。(如果严重亡失津液,则不能作汗,所以必须等待阴阳自和才能痊愈。)太阳病三天,已经发汗,或者经过催吐、攻下、温针治疗后仍不解的,这叫坏证。此时桂枝汤不再适用。应当观察病人的脉象和证候,知道犯了什么错误,根据证候进行治疗。
朱肱(活人)说:未满三天可以发汗治愈,满三天可以泄下治愈。这只是大略而言。凡是病患有虚有实,邪气传受迟速不同,怎么能拘泥于日数呢?张仲景说:日数虽多,只要有表证而脉浮的,仍然适宜发汗;日数虽少,如果有里证而脉沉的,就适宜攻下。正应随脉治疗。更何况六气之邪乘虚侵入经络,如从背部感受,则入太阳经或入少阴经;从面部感受,则入阳明经之类,不一定都始于太阳经。兼夹寒邪,有的从头到尾只在一经,有的间传一二经,不可以一概而论,只需视脉象和外证进行治疗,这是灵活的方法。假使有人脉浮,头项强痛,发热而恶寒,每天如此,不论日数多少,正是太阳经受病。其余各经都仿照此例。大抵伤寒只凭脉象与外证来决定汗下之法。如果过了很多天,脉象仍然大浮数,但按之不足,仍然责之于太阳,可以发汗而愈。如果按之实,发汗必死,必须攻下而愈。如果初起脉沉细数,外证或有腹满咽干,或口燥舌干而渴,为热邪正属于里,可攻下而愈。如果没有这些证候,表热而脉沉,误用攻下必死,必须用麻黄附子甘草汤或麻黄细辛附子汤,轻微发汗来治疗。这些都是张仲景的确切论述。
戴元礼说:伤寒的关键在于分辨表里,从而决定汗下。有病患自汗、自下利的,有医生用药发汗、攻下的,中间环节很多。发汗宜早,攻下宜迟,这也是大纲之论。比如失血家不可发汗,淋家不可发汗,这类情况岂能急于使用表剂?应当徐徐解散。如果不当汗而强发汗,则津液耗竭,变生百病,因此夭折,怎么能一概说“汗药宜早”?阳明病汗出多,宜急下;少阴病下利而渴,宜急下;厥阴病舌卷囊缩,宜急下。这类证候应当用速利之剂。如果当下而不攻下,则热毒转深,导致失下不可救疗,怎么能一概说“下药宜迟”?
李东垣(洁古)说:伤寒之法,先言表里及缓急。三阳病,表证当急治,里证当缓治;三阴病,表证当缓治,里证当急治。又说:脉浮当发汗,脉沉当攻下。脉浮汗急而下缓,是指三阳表证;脉沉下急而汗缓,是指三阴里证。麻黄汤称为急汗,麻黄附子细辛汤称为缓汗。《内经》说:“渍形以为汗”,是指汗之缓,即里的表证;又说:“在皮者,汗而发之”,是指汗之急,即表的表证。急汗者是太阳,缓汗者是少阴,这是脏腑输注相应的关系。假使附子麻黄细辛汤,是少阴证初起发热,脉沉,里和无汗,故用渍形为汗。今麻黄汤,是太阳证,头项痛,腰脊强,脉浮无汗,里和,是在皮者汗而发之,可以。经曰:“治主以缓,治客以急”,说的就是这个意思。(麻黄汤方见太阳病章节)
假使诊得肝脉,其外证为面色善青,易怒,三部脉俱弦而浮,恶寒,里和,二便自调。此为胆经受病,因肝主风。在麻黄汤内加羌活、防风各三钱。假使诊得心脉,其外证为面赤,口干,喜笑,尺寸脉俱浮而洪,恶寒,里和,二便自调。此为小肠经受病,因心主热。在麻黄汤内加黄芩、石膏各三钱。假使诊得脾脉,其外证为面黄,善噫,善思,好味,尺寸脉俱浮而缓,里和,恶寒。此为胃经受病,因脾主湿。在麻黄汤内加白术、防风各三钱。假使诊得肺脉,其外证为面白,善嚏,悲愁不乐,欲哭,尺寸脉俱浮而涩,里和,恶寒。此为大肠经受病,因肺主燥。在麻黄汤内加桂枝、生姜各三钱。假使诊得肾脉,其外证为面黑,善恐,欠伸,尺寸脉俱沉,里和,恶寒。此为膀胱经受病,因肾主寒。在麻黄汤内加附子、生姜各三钱。
以上五证皆属“表之表”,谓病在皮,急汗而发之,皆腑经受病。“表之里”者,攻下当缓。谓随脏表证外显,尺寸脉俱浮,而复有里证,谓发热饮水,小便便利色赤,或泄下赤水。其脉浮按之内实,或痛。用麻黄汤方,去麻黄、杏仁,随脏原本加药同煎,分作五服。每下一证,初一服加大黄五分,如邪未尽,又加大黄一钱,未尽再加大黄一钱半,直候邪尽则止。这是先缓而后急,是表之里,宜下之,当缓也。
假使诊得肝脉,其内证为满闷,淋沥,便难,转筋,尺寸脉俱沉而弦,里和,恶寒。此为肝经受病。在麻黄附子细辛汤内加羌活、防风各三钱。假使诊得心脉,其内证为烦心,心痛,掌中热而哕,尺寸脉俱沉洪,里和,恶寒。此为心经受病。在前汤内加黄芩、石膏各三钱。假使诊得脾脉,其内证为腹满胀,食不消,怠惰嗜卧,尺寸脉俱沉缓,里和,恶寒。此为肺经受病(注:原文此处疑有误,脾病通常关联脾胃,但原文写肺经,依原文翻译),加白术、防己各三钱。假使诊得肺脉,其内证为喘嗽,洒淅寒热,尺寸脉俱沉涩,里和,恶寒。此为肺经受病,加生姜、桂枝各三钱。假使诊得肾脉,其内证为泄泻,下重,足胫寒而逆,尺寸脉俱沉,里和,恶寒。此为肾经受病,加姜、附各三钱。
以上五证属“里之表”,宜清形以为汗,皆脏经受病。“里之里”者,攻下当急。谓随脏内证已显,尺寸脉俱沉,而复有里证,谓小便赤大,大便秘涩,或泻下赤水,或泻或咳,不能饮食,不恶风寒,发热引饮。其脉俱沉,按之内实而痛。此谓里实,宜速下之。用麻黄附子细辛汤,去麻黄,随脏原本加药同煮,分作三服。每下一证,初一服加大黄三钱,邪尽即止。如邪未尽,第二服加大黄二钱,又未尽,第三服加大黄一钱。这是先急而后缓,是里之里,宜速下之。
This is a flexible method for treating Shanghan (Cold Damage Syndrome). If swallowing is difficult when eating, it indicates that the pathogenic factor is not in the Stomach; if there is no desire to eat due to clouded consciousness, this is also the case. Since the heat pathogen is not in the Stomach, mistakenly using Chengqi Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Rhubarb Decoction) to purge will inevitably lead to death.
According to the theory of *Shanghan Lun* (Treatise on Cold Damage), pathogens typically transmit through the Foot meridians. Extending this logic to the Hand meridians reveals the secrets of disease mechanism. This generally occurs because pathogens accumulate over time, causing excess in the Foot meridians and deficiency in the Hand meridians, resulting in constrained heat. Transmission may result from errors in sweating or purging methods, or from emotional disturbances and fatigue. Generally, transmission to the Hand meridians has specific causes, which is why ancient physicians developed methods such as Rescue Ni (Correcting Deviation) and Reviving Pulse. These methods not only address the condition accurately but also establish principles for future generations.
Shanghan diseases usually originate from Wind-Cold pathogens. Initially located in the Exterior, if the pathogen enters the Interior, it cannot dissipate spontaneously. With proper warming and covering, spontaneous resolution is possible. Before attempting internal clearance, one must first release the Exterior; only then can purging be considered. If the Exterior is resolved but internal stagnation remains, unless there is significant fullness, chills and fever will persist, and the disease will not be cured. However, if the Exterior is resolved and internal stagnation presents with significant fullness, solid accumulation, hardness, and dry feces, purging is appropriate. Even if four or five days have passed, this will not cause harm. Conversely, if purging is inappropriate and forced, it leads to internal deficiency, allowing heat to enter and combine with cold, causing diarrhea, irritability, and numerous other complications. Mild cases become severe, and severe cases may result in death.
When Yang is excessive and Yin is deficient, sweating leads to death, while purging leads to recovery. When Yang is deficient and Yin is excessive, sweating leads to recovery, while purging leads to death. Thus, how can potent emetics like Shendan (Divine Pill) be misused for sweating? How can drastic purgatives like Kansui (Kansui Root) be recklessly used for attacking excess? The treatments for deficiency and excess are opposites, leading to outcomes separated by thousands of miles. The difference between life and death hinges on a moment. Observing the patient's entire condition leaves no time to count days. Once Guizhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is ingested, excessive Yang leads to death; once Chengqi Tang enters the Stomach, excessive Yin leads to demise. Life and death depend on an instant. Observing the whole body leaves no leisure to calculate days. This represents the interlacing of Yin-Yang and deficiency-excess. The signs are subtle, yet the consequences of reversing sweating, vomiting, and purging methods are swift. Physicians with shallow knowledge, ignorant of the disease source, treat erroneously, causing patients' deaths, yet claiming their actions were correct, until vengeful spirits fill the underworld and corpses litter the wilderness. Would not benevolent scholars grieve upon witnessing this?
For Lianggan Bing (Simultaneous Taiyang and Shaoyin involvement), treatment priorities differ: releasing the Exterior and purging the Interior are distinct. Yet, misguided practitioners claim that mixing Shendan and Kansui can simultaneously resolve the Exterior and clear the Interior. Although the rhetoric sounds clever, the principle violates medical logic. What the wise do, the foolish mimic. If this method truly determined safety and danger so quickly, would it not be miraculous? Most people pursue worldly glory, ignoring impending disaster. Only the enlightened protect the root, taking examples from themselves without needing to look far.
When administering sweating therapy, decoctions should be taken warm. Although instructions say three doses daily, if the condition is severe and unrelieved, intervals should be shortened, completing three doses within half a day. If symptoms conflict with the treatment, monitor closely. For severe cases, observe throughout the day and night. If symptoms persist after one dose, continue with the same decoction. Some patients may require three doses before sweating occurs; failure to sweat indicates a fatal prognosis. After taking Guizhi Tang, if profuse sweating occurs with a surging pulse, administer Guizhi Tang again according to previous methods. If half a day later, vexation returns with a floating and rapid pulse, sweating may be induced again. (*Huo Ren Shu* states: If symptoms persist after sweating, two or three sweating sessions within three days are permissible, aiming for perspiration from waist down. Caution is required; do not act rashly.) Stop medication once the disease is addressed; do not necessarily complete the full course. The same applies to vomiting and purging therapies.
Xu Xicheng recorded a case: A villager had Shanghan with fever, constipation, vexation, thirst, and dizziness. The physician used Radix Crotonis Fructus (Badou, Castor Bean) to purge. The patient soon had loose stools, but the illness remained unchanged. I observed that Yangming heat was bound internally, requiring Da Chaihu Tang (Major Bupleurum Decoction) or Chengqi Tang. Badou only removes accumulation but cannot cleanse toxic heat. I urgently prescribed Da Chaihu Tang. After three doses, the patient sweated and recovered. Zhang Zhongjing’s 113 formulas include only five pills: Lizhong Wan, Xiongxiong Wan, Didang Wan, Wumei Wan, and Maren Wan. Lizhong, Xiongxiong, and Didang pills are large (like marbles), boiled and taken like decoctions. Maren Wan for Pi Yue (Spleen Constraint) and Wumei Wan for damp dysentery use small pills to reach lower areas. Other formulas for expelling toxins, breaking masses, moving blood stasis, or moistening dryness rely on decoctions. It is unheard of to use small pills of Badou to purge pathogens. If purging fails to resolve the disease, adding Radix et Rhizoma Rhei (Dahuang, Rhubarb) and Natrii Sulfas (Mangxiao, Mirabilite) further damages healthy Qi.
In any disease, whether treated by sweating, vomiting, purging, or fluid loss, if Yin and Yang achieve self-harmony, the disease will heal spontaneously. (Severe fluid loss prevents sweating, so healing depends on natural restoration of balance.) In Taiyang disease, if after three days of sweating, vomiting, purging, or warm needle therapy the condition persists, it is termed "Huai Zheng" (Damaged Syndrome). Guizhi Tang is no longer suitable. Observe the pulse and symptoms, identify the error, and treat according to the current presentation.
Zhu Gong stated: Diseases under three days can be treated by sweating; those over three days by purging. This is a generalization. Patients vary in deficiency and excess, and pathogen transmission speeds differ; one cannot rigidly adhere to day counts. Zhang Zhongjing said: Many days with exterior signs and a floating pulse still warrant sweating; few days with interior signs and a sinking pulse warrant purging. Treatment must follow the pulse. Furthermore, Six Qi pathogens enter meridians based on weakness: back exposure affects Taiyang or Shaoyin; face exposure affects Yangming. Not all begin in Taiyang. Cold pathogens may stay in one meridian or spread to others. Treatment depends on pulse and external signs—this is flexibility. For example, a floating pulse with stiff neck, headache, fever, and aversion to cold indicates Taiyang involvement, regardless of duration. Other meridians follow similar patterns. Generally, Shanghan treatment relies on pulse and signs. If days pass but the pulse remains floating and rapid, though weak upon pressure, it still relates to Taiyang and can be cured by sweating. If firm upon pressure, sweating is fatal; purging is required. If initial pulse is sinking, fine, and rapid, with abdominal fullness, dry throat, or thirst, heat is interior, and purging is curative. Without these signs, if there is exterior heat but a sinking pulse, mistaken purging is fatal; use Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang (Ephedra, Aconite, and Licorice Decoction) or Ma Huang Xi Xin Fu Zi Tang (Ephedra, Asarum, and Aconite Decoction) for mild sweating. These are Zhongjing’s definitive teachings.
Dai Yuanli emphasized distinguishing Exterior and Interior for sweating and purging. Spontaneous sweating or diarrhea differs from iatrogenic induction. Sweating should be early; purging late. However, patients with blood loss or stranguria should not be abruptly treated with exterior-releasing agents; gradual resolution is needed. Forced sweating depletes fluids, causing myriad complications and premature death. One cannot simply say "sweating is early." Conversely, Yangming with profuse sweating, Shaoyin with diarrhea and thirst, and Jueyin with curled tongue and retracted testicles require urgent purging. Delaying purging allows heat toxicity to deepen, becoming incurable. One cannot simply say "purging is late."
Li Dongyuan stated: Shanghan treatment prioritizes Exterior/Interior and urgency. For Three Yang diseases, Exterior requires urgent treatment, Interior slow; for Three Yin, Exterior slow, Interior urgent. Floating pulse warrants sweating; sinking pulse warrants purging. Floating pulse with urgent sweating and slow purging indicates Three Yang Exterior. Sinking pulse with urgent purging and slow sweating indicates Three Yin Interior. Ma Huang Tang is "urgent sweating"; Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang is "slow sweating." *Neijing* says "steeping the form to induce sweat" refers to slow sweating (Exterior of Interior). "Releasing what is in the skin" refers to urgent sweating (Exterior of Exterior). Urgent sweating targets Taiyang; slow sweating targets Shaoyin, corresponding to organ meridians. Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang treats early Shaoyin fever with sinking pulse, interior harmony, and no sweat (steeping method). Ma Huang Tang treats Taiyang headache, stiff neck, floating pulse, no sweat, and interior harmony (releasing skin method). *Classic* states: "Treat the principal slowly, the guest urgently."
If Liver pulse is detected: exterior signs include bluish complexion, anger, string-like and floating pulses, aversion to cold, harmonious interior, normal urination/defecation. This indicates Gallbladder meridian involvement due to Liver governing wind. Add Qiang Huo (Notopterygium Root) and Fang Feng (Siler Root), 3 qian each, to Ma Huang Tang. If Heart pulse is detected: exterior signs include red face, dry mouth, laughter, floating and surging pulses, aversion to cold, harmonious interior. This indicates Small Intestine meridian involvement due to Heart governing heat. Add Huang Qin (Scutellaria Root) and Shi Gao (Gypsum), 3 qian each, to Ma Huang Tang. If Spleen pulse is detected: exterior signs include yellow face, belching, overthinking, taste preference, floating and moderate pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. This indicates Stomach meridian involvement due to Spleen governing dampness. Add Bai Zhu (Atractylodes Rhizome) and Fang Feng, 3 qian each, to Ma Huang Tang. If Lung pulse is detected: exterior signs include pale face, sneezing, sorrow, weeping, floating and choppy pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. This indicates Large Intestine meridian involvement due to Lung governing dryness. Add Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) and Sheng Jiang (Fresh Ginger), 3 qian each, to Ma Huang Tang. If Kidney pulse is detected: exterior signs include dark face, fear, yawning, sinking pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. This indicates Bladder meridian involvement due to Kidney governing cold. Add Fu Zi (Aconite Lateral Root) and Sheng Jiang, 3 qian each, to Ma Huang Tang.
These five conditions are "Exterior of Exterior," indicating pathogen in the skin, requiring urgent sweating, affecting Fu organs. "Exterior of Interior" requires slow purging. Signs include exterior manifestations, floating pulses, plus interior signs like fever, thirst, red urine, or bloody diarrhea. Pulses float but feel solid upon pressure, or pain exists. Remove Ma Huang and Xing Ren (Apricot Seed) from Ma Huang Tang, add organ-specific herbs, boil, divide into five doses. Start with 5 fen Da Huang (Rhubarb); increase by 1 qian if pathogens remain, then another 1.5 qian until cleared. This is "slow then urgent," for purging Exterior of Interior.
If Liver pulse shows interior signs: distension, dribbling, difficult defecation, tendon cramping, sinking and string-like pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. Liver meridian disease. Add Qiang Huo and Fang Feng, 3 qian each, to Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang. If Heart pulse shows interior signs: vexation, heart pain, hot palms, hiccups, sinking and surging pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. Heart meridian disease. Add Huang Qin and Shi Gao, 3 qian each, to the previous decoction. If Spleen pulse shows interior signs: abdominal fullness, indigestion, lethargy, sinking and moderate pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. Lung meridian disease (Note: Text says Lung, likely error for Stomach/Spleen context, but translated as written). Add Bai Zhu and Fang Ji (Stephania Root), 3 qian each. If Lung pulse shows interior signs: cough, chills/fevers, sinking and choppy pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. Lung meridian disease. Add Sheng Jiang and Gui Zhi, 3 qian each. If Kidney pulse shows interior signs: diarrhea, heaviness, cold legs, sinking pulses, harmonious interior, aversion to cold. Kidney meridian disease. Add Sheng Jiang and Fu Zi, 3 qian each.
These five conditions are "Interior of Exterior," requiring steaming/sweating, affecting Zang organs. "Interior of Interior" requires urgent purging. Signs include interior manifestations, sinking pulses, plus interior signs like red copious urine, constipation, bloody diarrhea, cough, inability to eat/drink, aversion to neither wind nor cold, fever, and thirst. Pulses sink and feel solid/painful upon pressure. This is Interior Excess, requiring rapid purging. Use Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang, remove Ma Huang, add organ-specific herbs, boil, divide into three doses. Start with 3 qian Da Huang; stop if pathogens clear. If not cleared, second dose adds 2 qian; third dose adds 1 qian. This is "urgent then slow," for purging Interior of Interior.